3 ms·
You're calculating the resting potential energy, aren't you? "Dropping a tungsten rod on earth" is not picking it up and dropping it. It's firing it at the ear
by hinkley 6y ago
You're calculating the resting potential energy, aren't you?
"Dropping a tungsten rod on earth" is not picking it up and dropping it. It's firing it at the earth. Depending on what body you're firing it from, that's a lot of additional delta v.
Something coming at the earth from the Moon, for instance, is moving at least 2.3 kps, plus another kps if you fire it forward. This calculator is telling me that's 55.2 gigajoules, about 15 thousand times higher.
Assuming your math is right, and then my math is right, .35 megatons is still an exceedingly bad day.
- xyzzyz 6y ago> Something coming at the earth from the Moon, for instance, is moving at least 2.3 kps, plus another kps if you fire it forward. What do you mean "fire it forward"? If you fire it forward, it will never fall on Earth. To get from Moon to Earth, you need to fire it backward in Moon orbit, to slow it down. Essentially, you need to slow it down a lot if you want it to get to Earth surface, as opposed to orbiting it alongside Moon.
- hinkley 6y agoNot if it’s in an elliptical orbit with a low enough apogee.
- elihu 6y agoYeah, I was ignoring sideways velocity. I was taking "just look up what happens when you drop a 10ton tungsten rod from outer-space" perhaps a bit too literally. If we add in 1/2 * 10,000 kg * (7500 m/s)^2, to account for sideways LEO-equivalent momentum, I have it coming out as about 0.0906 kilotons: about 4 times more energy. Which isn't too surprising, since the hardest part about getting into orbit isn't the going up part, it's the going sideways fast enough enough part. My whole formula is this: (((10000 * 9.8 * 1000000) + (0.5 * 10000 * (7500 * 7500))) / 3600000) / 1162200 Basically, (mgh + 1/2 mv^2) converted from joules to kilowatt hours to get it into a larger unit I can sort of relate to, and then converting that in turn to kilotons equivalent TNT in order to compare with nuclear yields. That's assuming I didn't leave off some zeroes somewhere or apply a formula incorrectly.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]