9 ms·
>Proof of stake lets players with the most money have the most say. Okay, and what do you think the mining equipment is acquired with exactly?
by Barrin92 6y ago
>Proof of stake lets players with the most money have the most say.
Okay, and what do you think the mining equipment is acquired with exactly?
- izolate 6y agoIt's the non-mining nodes that verify transactions and have the final say, and those can be run on home devices by regular people. That's the difference.
- ses1984 6y agoNon mining nodes do diddly squat.
- inter_netuser 6y agoNonsense. If miners's new block isnt accepted by the network - they've just lost millions. Rules are enforced by block verification of the nodes that accept - or refuse to accept mined blocks. It's amazing that in 2021 people still do not understand the basics of it.
- zapdrive 6y agoNon mining nodes are programmed to follow the longest chain. That's so they are: readers. They are not writers. They act like slave nodes in a database. They have insignificant power in the grand scheme of things.
- nlitened 6y agoLongest _valid_ chain. Invalid blocks are just ignored.
- ses1984 6y agoThat’s what miners do as well.
- nlitened 6y agoYes. I just wanted to emphasize that in PoW coins, a rogue miner cannot force the whole network to accept blocks because all network participants (even passive non-miners) will just ignore the "invalid" block.
- ses1984 6y agoNo, but if all the miners fork from all the non mining nodes, the chain with all the miners will be more secure. If a minority of miners side with the non mining nodes, that chain will be more vulnerable to disruption.
- inter_netuser 6y agoWould you hire a security company again, if they refused to protect you when the push comes to shove? That's all miners are. Mercenaries hired for 10 minutes at a time.
- ses1984 6y agoYeah exactly. Not sure if you realize the implication of what happens if you arm a bunch of mercenaries and then fire them and turn your backs on them.
- inter_netuser 6y agoThis has already played out. The breakaway hostile fork is now worth 2 percent of the original work. So..nothing?
- ses1984 6y ago
- inter_netuser 6y agoMiners don't really have much say, they cannot impose rules on the network, unlike PoS stakers. PoS malicious stakers lose nothing in case of a split. Miners should they attempt a 51% attack will lose everything. Not even in the same category.
- Sargos 6y ago>PoS malicious stakers lose nothing in case of a split You can only support one side of a fork in PoS and if you try to play both sides anyone can form a proof showing you mined both forks and your stake gets slashed. This is the Nothing At Stake problem and well understood which makes your comment pretty confusing.
- inter_netuser 6y agohow do you objectively find out who is the attacker, so that you do not slash the victim on accident?
- Sargos 6y agoCan you give an example of what you mean? There are no attackers or victims in the scenario of the chain forking and a block producer gooing out of their way to mine both chains with the same stake.
- inter_netuser 6y agothe chain splits in two. how do you know which one to continue staking on to avoid getting slashed?
- Sargos 6y agoBy default your validator software picks the unmodified chain unless you install a special update that lets it use the newly forked chain. If you do nothing you continue mining just one chain (the old one) and nothing is lost. If you validate with both then you are penalized. That can't really be done on accident.