3 ms·
It's their country and their rules. If local broadcast has to play by them, so should internet TV. It's also good so they preserve whatever distinctness they
by mc32 6y ago
It's their country and their rules. If local broadcast has to play by them, so should internet TV. It's also good so they preserve whatever distinctness they have from "global" culture and retain and promote their own.
- polishdude20 6y agoIn some sense I agree but in another, as a user, I don't want Canadian stuff to be recommended to me because it's Canadian. I want content to succeed by merit alone at least when it comes to the internet. Do I care that some YouTuber is a Canadian? Not really.
- vibrolax 6y agoI think it would be nice if we could search media content by country of origin. I'm a US citizen living in Canada, and I anecdotally feel that YouTube recommends lots of Canadian content, but not nearly as high a percentage as the broadcasters are required to do.
- kortilla 6y ago> If local broadcast has to play by them, so should internet TV. That would make sense if it was anything like broadcast TV where users have no control and its public airwaves. Instead this is a private website where users decide what to watch. This isn’t meaningfully different from requiring people to suggest Canadian content when chatting with each other online.
- munk-a 6y agoThis bill doesn't actually interfere with sought content - it is more concerned with algorithms related to surfacing new content. No video is going to be banned or forced on people, but if you leave YouTube on autoplay you'll hit a lot more Canadian creators. At least, that is the intent.
- mynegation 6y agoCanadian here. While I support these initiatives in general, 40% is way excessive. Given that Canada is 10x smaller than US, 20% would be a nice handicap. Execution, as others pointed out, is a bit sloppy too. I would prefer to listen to lesser known and varied Canadian artists, like Faouzia or Coeur de Pirate, but no! - let’s roll out the same Drake, Bieber, and Weeknd over and over again.
- throwawaysea 6y agoI am surprised to see the “their country their rules” sentiment here. Why doesn’t the HN crowd offer the same reprieve to developing nations like China or India, when they try to regulate social media, retain their culture/identity/politics, and defend against the immense influence of American culture/media/activism? What makes the two different? I find this Canadian bill to be pretty egregious because it will subject user submitted media to CRTC content guidelines. That could just as easily mean, for example, preventing speech on controversial topics like gender identity unless they align with the current (left biased) ruling government’s perspective.
- munk-a 6y agoI think the difference is that this isn't being used as a tool of political suppression the way that China tries to control various tech companies. Instead it's just as valid to argue that forcing Canadians to accept 100% freely chosen content is an American value that the US is trying to force on us. I don't mean to say that 40% is definitely the right ratio - but what societal factors are most free are going to differ from country to country. The US enthusiastically embraces the free-market as the salve for all ills - elsewhere government intervention is viewed as being more free and responsible since it can shield residents from the levels undue economic hardship that can strike Americans when it comes to trying to pay medical bills. What is most free is not a definite objective thing, and I would note that this bill is only targeting how companies need to operate within Canada while the US has a plethora of laws dictating how companies need to act across the world in order to participate in the US market.
- throwawaysea 6y agoWhat are your thoughts on the fact that this bill may give the controlling government authority on what content is allowed and what gets prominently featured? Can this not be a used to amplify certain ideologies while suppressing others? Whatever the stated intent is, I would argue the law should not permit any encroachment on something as fundamental as free speech. It seems former members of the CRTC do see this bill as enabling an attack on free speech (https://www.theglobeandmail.com/politics/article-former-crtc-chair-says-bill-c-10-should-not-be-passed-in-its-present/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/politics/article-former-crtc...).