3 ms·
Realistically, ransomware will just never stop until IT systems are sufficiently hardened.
by sudosysgen 6y ago
Realistically, ransomware will just never stop until IT systems are sufficiently hardened.
- user3939382 6y agoOr sufficiently backed up, right? If you’ve got a backup and quick recovery process ransomware is impotent.
- salawat 6y agoThis is by far the cheapest solution.
- phkahler 6y agounless your data is legally required to stay confidential under HIPPA or similar law. Then a backup just keeps you operating but not immune to the threat of data publication.
- johnvaluk 6y agoWhile the threat of publication is a risk, the data has already been breached and you are no longer compliant with the law.
- mateo- 6y agoI wonder if companies still get fined if the data is just encrypted without any exfil
- dragontamer 6y agoWhat data needs to be confidential in the case of the Colonial Pipeline? I'm sure that there's proprietary data. Maybe knowing how much oil / gasoline is flowing might allow some traders to make unfairly informed trades (or maybe not: only inside trading is illegal. If someone figures out the information some other way, its not illegal IIRC). And maybe employee data should be kept private, but there's no HIPPA requirement on that. Its not like there's payment processors on this thing either, so no PCI compliance here. So I'm not exactly seeing why backing up data would be an issue in this case.
- viraptor 6y agoNot quite. The attacker still got access to the system in some way. They may have a permanent backdoor now and opportunity for messing with your backup operation.
- uses 6y agoNowadays the attackers will threaten to disclose the sensitive data publicly, as they did in this case. So ensuring your own access to your data, i.e. backups, is not the only concern. It's still important, of course.
- speed_spread 6y agoIf hackers take the slow route, all backups may be encrypted too. Or at least, compromised. Also, backups are often taken but rarely is their actual recoverability tested.
- throwaway6734 6y agoAnd if the penalty for hacking systems for malicious purpose goes up. Hopefully every member of DarkSide ends up in court if they're US or friendly nation citizens or in Gitmo otherwise
- lurquer 6y agoNah. It will never stop. The problem is information density. So long as billions of records that are needed for the business exist in a device the size of a shoebox, we’re fucked. An insider can always take the shoebox, lock the shoebox, etc. Three stories of paper files in file cabinets can’t be ransomed short of a physical bomb threat. Don’t know what the solution is. But I do know the problem. Exfiltrarion is similar: the odd quirk of technology that has enabled these massive thefts is the ability to load millions of pages in a few seconds into a thumb drive. Odd pickle we’ve got ourselves into.
- mrtesthah 6y agoYour metaphor works both ways: the ability to fit billions of records in a shoebox means that it’s perfectly manageable to keep another shoebox as a backup, under independent control.
- lurquer 6y agoSo now there are two shoeboxes. Hasn’t solved exfiltration. In fact, you’ve just doubled the risk. There may not be a solution if the problem is untrustworthy people. The custodians of your ‘independent control’ will eventually get ransomwared themselves. Then what? It’s like cash... If you are a sophisticated criminal, do you waste time burglarizing individuals? Or, do you rob the bank where the individuals keep their money for ‘safekeeping’? How many people at Amazon have access to the database other companies use to store info? 2? 20? 200? I don’t know, but I bet it’s a lot. And I doubt they get paid enough to make them immune to a generous offer (or a scary threat) from a bad guy. Seriously, how many individuals at Amazon have the ability — if they wanted - to irreparable corrupt, encrypt, or destroy data?
- mrtesthah 6y agoI thought we were talking about denying access to important files. Data exfiltration is a different threat model than what I was addressing.
- hellbannedguy 6y ago
- jorvi 6y agoSome ransomware is time-delayed because of this, so it isn't clear which backup is still untainted.