3 ms·
OK everyone, calm down. Let me explain what these internet companies are asking for. Essentially they want the telecoms to pay us, the American Taxpayers, BIL
by bilbo0s 19y ago
OK everyone, calm down.
Let me explain what these internet companies are asking for. Essentially they want the telecoms to pay us, the American Taxpayers, BILLIONS for access to wireless spectrum. Subsequently, they want these telecoms to be obliged to let them use the same wireless spectrum for free.
Did I mention that the wireless spectrum is OURS?
That it is the sole property of the American Citizenry?
Start standing up for your rights people. Either EVERYONE pays US for access to OUR spectrum, or NO ONE does. Look at it this way, on average, many would say a black guy is more cool than any other guy. That said, if one comes into MY store and wants MY product, he will pay the same price as everyone else. Any other method of operating is known as DISCRIMINATION. If Google wants to use OUR spectrum, they are welcome to bid on it like everyone else.
But come here Google . . . a little closer I have to tell you a secret. WE are probably going to charge you a good deal more for usage rights to that spectrum than the telecoms want to charge you to sub-lease it. It's because our government needs the money and . . . Oh who am I kidding . . . I just love sticking it to huge companies like yours. I don't care what the other reasons are. By the way, we also have laws that limit your ability to pass those costs on to the consumers, typically us. That's because WE want to be able to access the spectrum as close to free as possible, even after we sell the usage rights to it. You know why? That's right . . . because it is OUR SPECTRUM!
I apologize for this rant. It just seems to me that when a company like F@#K!^& GOOGLE is whining about something like this, the cult of victimization in this nation has officially reached its farcical zenith. The people who started that company, AND the early employees for that matter, have more money than 99.9999999% of us. Yet STILL, they want us to give them even more of the few of our resources that they don't already own for FREE!!!
I have to stop working Sundays...
- nostrademons 19y agoThat wasn't the proposal in the article. It was for a segment of the wireless spectrum to be auctioned off with the restriction that it be open to any device that meets certain specifications. The big-4 wireless carriers can keep their allotted bands; this is a new part of the electromagnetic spectrum that is scheduled to be auctioned off shortly anyway. If the wireless spectrum is OURS (as in, the U.S. peoples'), it makes sense that we can restrict its usage in whatever way would benefit the people most. It also makes sense that one such way would be to restrict its usage so that the buyer cannot restrict other firms' usage of it. It's essentially an easement. You know what an easement is, right: the owner of the property sells off certain rights and restrictions to a third-party. For example, power companies will buy an easement to run high-tension lines over a field. Wealthy individuals will sell an easement stating that their land will become conservation land after their death, and the owner will be prohibited from developing certain areas. In this case, the government is giving an easement for open-access to the general public, and selling off the remaining rights to that portion the EM spectrum to the highest bidder. There is no economic reason why this chunk would sell for higher than the existing telecoms' slices. Its usage rights are restricted: generally, an easement lowers the value of the remaining property rights, since you can do less with it. Also, if you read the article, you'll notice that it's being auctioned off, which means the government isn't setting a price, it's selling it to the highest bidder, who will presumably be responsible for developing the network and putting up cell towers. Actually, if I had a few billion dollars in funding and a plan for putting up cell towers more cheaply than the established carriers, I'd buy it. This could be a game-changer on the same order as Intel's invention of the microprocessor. Before Intel, the minicomputer field was much like the wireless field, with many vertically-integrated carriers stifling innovation. Because Intel (and Microsoft) decided to focus only on one area and relentlessly lower costs, letting others innovate in the app sphere, the PC market exploded. We all know how it worked out for Intel and Microsoft... Even if the government doesn't grant this easement, a savvy investor should swoop in and make that portion of the spectrum open-access anyway. There's potentially a massive market there. Too bad I don't have a billion dollars...
- bilbo0s 19y agoAlright, firstly if you read my post I said Google is free to BID on the spectrum like everyone else. It is my hope that these bids run into the BILLIONS, we should get our cut. Secondly, an easement brings down the price for the reasons you outlined. However, there will be NO restrictions on HOW the winners use this spectrum. Only a provision that they let other cheap bastards who are not paying us use the spectrum as well, for FREE. Now as long as EVERYONE pays I am happy. Yet when ONLY the telecoms have to pay, and the internet companies ride for free, the American People are losing money. I spend the summers in Paris, and I can tell you that the American People can ill afford to give things away for free. 1 Euro is about US$1.34 right now. The fact that the price would be lower for this spectrum is EXACTLY what INCENSES me. These people will make BILLIONS, and you want us to let them weasel out of the spectrum fees. They already have a myriad of different options for weaseling out of our ability to tax them on the back end. With all due respect, sir, we must agree to disagree. To everyone else, believe me, I'm wealthy enough. If the majority of us wish to continue to give more and more to the wealthy in exchange for less and less, then that is democracy and I will go along with it. It will benefit me after all. I am simply stating my belief that it is contrary to the interests of other social classes.