7 ms·
Walled gardens are just security theater. The App Store revenue was $72bn in 2020, yet the review time for an app is a few hours. App reviewers barely have any
by oblio 6y ago
Walled gardens are just security theater. The App Store revenue was $72bn in 2020, yet the review time for an app is a few hours. App reviewers barely have any qualifications, they're just "call center operators" running off a script.
- user-the-name 6y agoIt is a lot more than "theatre". The first line of defence is the sandboxing built into the OS. The second line is a lot of automated analysis of the binaries that are uploaded. The human review is the third line, but that is much less about security.
- dalbasal 6y ago..and the last line of defense is removing a bad app to prevent further harm. Drivers licenses aren't only about competence. Sure, there's a test. But, there's also the ability to revoke a license.
- Siira 6y agoSo please explain why the licenses need to cost a fortune? Simple Bayesian thinking will tell you what the real motive is, and what is being used as the coverup motive.
- dalbasal 6y agoThere is no "real" motive, only history. One thing led to another. Now we are here.
- user-the-name 6y agoIs $99 a year really "a fortune"? It's less than the price of a Netflix subscription.
- threeseed 6y agoa) Apple has invested heavily in automated review methods over the years. b) I don't know what qualifications you think an app reviewer needs. They are not looking through the code but simply playing with the app on a range of devices. c) It is only a few hours for updates. Initial app submissions often take days/weeks and are very thorough.
- swiley 6y agoYour definition of "thorough" and mine are very different. I highly doubt they could do a meaningful review without the complete source code for the app. It's not unusual that apps change their behavior after the review and this sometimes comes from binary dylibs that the developer didn't write. The whole thing is a scam.
- zepto 6y ago> It's not unusual that apps change their behavior after the review Which leads to the account being banned. > and this sometimes comes from binary dylibs that the developer didn't write. Which are detected through analysis if they are common spyware. >The whole thing is a scam. Clearly not.
- swiley 6y ago>> It's not unusual that apps change their behavior after the review >Which leads to the account being banned. Only if it gets noticed. >> and this sometimes comes from binary dylibs that the developer didn't write. >Which are detected through analysis if they are common spyware. Facebook got away with it for many years. >>The whole thing is a scam. >Clearly not. If it weren't then they would let people choose to use the App Store. It only exists to protect Apple's services from competition.
- zepto 6y ago> Only if it gets noticed. True, but they are getting better at noticing. >> and this sometimes comes from binary dylibs that the developer didn't write. >Which are detected through analysis if they are common spyware. > Facebook got away with it for many years. You know about that because they were stopped. And since then Apple has tightened the rules and stepped up detection. >>The whole thing is a scam. >Clearly not. > If it weren't then they would let people choose to use the App Store. No, because that would enable social engineering attacks once again. > It only exists to protect Apple's services from competition. This is straight up bullshit. You keep saying it, but it’s false at face value. Millions of scams have been stopped. https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2021/05/app-store-stopped-over-1-5-billion-in-suspect-transactions-in-2020/ https://www.apple.com/newsroom/2021/05/app-store-stopped-ove...
- spoonjim 6y agoI've watched the App Store reviewers try out apps (not in person, from logging) and they do seem to do a pretty thorough job of exercising the functionality.
- danuker 6y agoHow do you know those were not automated systems?
- spoonjim 6y agoCould have been, but then we got rejected for something which would have been hard to detect automatically.
- mupuff1234 6y agoThat makes me wonder how easy it is to just hide certain features during the review process.
- bassdropvroom 6y agoVW should hire this person!
- oblio 6y agohttps://github.com/auchenberg/volkswagen https://github.com/auchenberg/volkswagen
- bugfix 6y agoIt is actually pretty easy. As long as you don't use any private APIs, you can completely change the behavior of your app after the review by changing server side settings.
- zepto 6y agoYes, but if they catch you, you’ll get kicked out of the store altogether.
- simias 6y agoIf we judge by the result these app store seem to do fairly well security-wise, no? Compared to Windows as a case study of what happens when you let users install anything they want from untrusted sources, it seems that the app stores do fairly well at culling obvious malware. At least that's what I experienced comparing the number of time I had to cleanup a friend or family member's computer filled with malware and browser toolbars vs. iphones and androids.
- zimbatm 6y agoA large part of the stability can be attributed to sandboxing. This is what prevents apps from gaining unprivileged access and destabilizing the system. This is the time where relatives will call you. What you don't see, is all the apps that steal the user's data. Curation obviously helps but it's difficult to measure to what extent.
- sneak 6y agoIt has to be both to work; the sandbox would fail in a day if there were no review/revocation system.
- nickflood 6y agoWeb browsers don't have widely known glaring security holes in them even though their vendors don't approve the content that's viewed through them. On the other hand, you can't be completely sure that sandboxes on mobile devices don't have actively exploited security issues as there are many ways to bypass app review from discovering the true functionality of an app.
- sneak 6y ago> Web browsers don't have widely known glaring security holes in them even though their vendors don't approve the content that's viewed through them. Anything widely known gets fixed quickly. There are plenty of holes in browser sandboxing. The number approximately doubles as soon as you look at anything !Chrome, too.
- kolinko 6y agoAnd yet, over it’s 13 years of history there were only single instances of viruses/malware. Compare that to Google Play
- grawprog 6y agohttps://www.techradar.com/news/apple-app-store-is-apparently-still-littered-with-malicious-apps https://www.techradar.com/news/apple-app-store-is-apparently... https://threatpost.com/click-fraud-malware-apple-app-store/149496/ https://threatpost.com/click-fraud-malware-apple-app-store/1... https://www.tomsguide.com/news/iphone-apps-infected-malware https://www.tomsguide.com/news/iphone-apps-infected-malware https://9to5mac.com/2021/05/07/emails-reveal-128-million-ios-users-were-affected-by-xcodeghost-malware/ https://9to5mac.com/2021/05/07/emails-reveal-128-million-ios... https://www.theiphonewiki.com/wiki/Malware_for_iOS https://www.theiphonewiki.com/wiki/Malware_for_iOS
- kolinko 6y agoDid you read the links you provided? The last article explicitly mentions that most of the malware needs iPhone to be jailbroken or the app to be installed outside of the App Store, which kind of proves my point. The research by Panda Security also showed that the ratio of malware on Android compared to iPhone is 50 to 1. https://www.pandasecurity.com/en/mediacenter/mobile-security/android-more-infected-than-ios/ https://www.pandasecurity.com/en/mediacenter/mobile-security...
- antipaul 6y agoDetails on app review process, including picture of reviewer workstation, surfaced in the Epic game trial: https://www.macrumors.com/2021/05/07/app-store-35-percent-of-apps-rejected/ https://www.macrumors.com/2021/05/07/app-store-35-percent-of...