4 ms·
Objectively, Covid-19 was a preventable disaster. From all around the world, the issue was governmental competence. Almost every government in the world did n
by sudosysgen 6y ago
Objectively, Covid-19 was a preventable disaster.
From all around the world, the issue was governmental competence.
Almost every government in the world did not treat the issue with the due amount of urgency.
Almost every government in the world screwed up on airborne transmission for a good while.
Almost every government downright minimized the issued and wasted precious months of time that could have been used to ramp up testing, set up contact tracing, and organize the initial lockdowns to be more effective. My country still doesn't have an effective contact tracing system with people employed there complaining of massive dysfunction, over a year in.
It's not for lack of power either - almost every government in the world has already assigned themselves a tremendous amount of emergency powers during pandemics and in general, from the authority to lockdown to mass surveillance.
Yet very few used this authority effectively. The governments that claimed not to want to use these powers by respect for civil rights overwhelmingly... Still reserve those powers to themselves and abuse them in ways that don't help.
Why is it that governments are so competent when it comes to mass surveillance and repression but completely fumble the ball in cases where governmental power is genuinely helpful and where the argument for them being justified is so much stronger?
- thatguy0900 6y ago"Why is it that governments are so competent when it comes to mass surveillance and repression" Are they? It seems alot of it is just ordering competent companies to do it for them
- sudosysgen 6y agoWell, you're definitely right that competent companies help a lot, but the government still does a lot of technical work in Five Eyes countries and in countries like China and Russia that have very strong mass surveillance too the government does a lot of the job.
- Nasrudith 6y agoI think the answer is different - the reason is because it is an 'Industrial Complex' regardless of any actual industry. Essentially if it works in a feedback loop of some sort whether it is 'more draconian security theater to help their career' or funneling money to donors then utility is irrelevant. If it is an end to itself then it is always 'competently done' even if it is a millstone around the neck of a nation.
- unishark 6y agoHow do you measure competence? China plays whack-a-mole with its population. They certainly haven't eliminated dissent. They have the world's largest army as the only real backstop against opposition.
- powerapple 6y agoAs a Chinese, I say Chinese government is really bad at PR and competent in dealing with issues given the circumstances. As you know China has been living through something comparable to 1920 - 2000 in last 20 - 30 years. Any thing you just think would work will stop working the next year, they are far from perfect, but I think they are doing a pretty good job so far. I think it is less about competent. It is actually are you willing to set out policy to solve the problem but lose your popularity? Is government is ready to make the hard choice? People can only do that during war time.
- cratermoon 6y ago> Why is it that governments are so competent when it comes to mass surveillance and repression $ 7,919,196,000 – CDC FY 2020 total funding $13,316,000,000 – CVN-78, USS Gerald R. Ford $62,000,000,000 – National Intelligence Program FY 2020
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- goldenkey 6y agoYes, let's give more funding to the CDC for Gain-of-Function research. Since it's been proven without a doubt that COVID originated naturally..../s
- cratermoon 6y agoDon't spread misinformation.
- refurb 6y agoThe general rule is those govts that were affected by past pandemics, SARS, Swine flu did the best (Vietnam, Singapore, Australia) while those that didn’t go through those pandemics didn’t do well. Practice helps.
- sofixa 6y agoThere's some nuance to government responses. In France for instance, there was recent history of the swine flu epidemic in 2009, where the government responded with urgency, mass buying of supplies and vaccines, and a mass vaccination drive; and it was a huge flop, they were ridiculed and criticized because the epidemic stopped by itself and all the resources were wasted. So subsequent governments were reluctant to jump too quickly to full on panic lockdown mode; what if it were "just a flu"? Nonetheless the Health minister was changed with an actual doctor in ~february, who has done pretty well since. It's easy to criticize with the benefit of hindsight.
- des1nderlase 6y ago>> Objectively, Covid-19 was a preventable disaster. >> From all around the world, the issue was governmental competence. But was it? Perhaps it was theoretically preventable but not in practice. Something across political systems, human psychology, religions makes it objectively non-preventable. I think governments didn't react correctly as this is the first time in the lifespan of many to happen. Countries that had similar outbreaks recently did well. I bet you Covid-22 will be handled differently.