6 ms·
> Uber transfered its intellectual property through a $16 billion “loan” from one of its subsidiaries in Singapore that in turn owns one of Uber’s Dutch shell c
by paxys 6y ago
> Uber transfered its intellectual property through a $16 billion “loan” from one of its subsidiaries in Singapore that in turn owns one of Uber’s Dutch shell companies, a manuever that grants the company a $1 billion tax break every year for the next 20 years, the researchers found.
Shit like this makes my head hurt and infuriates me at the same time.
- nceqs3 6y agoBe mad at politicians for writing tax codes that work like this rather than companies for taking advantage of them.
- jelling 6y agoNah let’s do both. If a company wants to spin a pro-social image - Uber is currently asking consumers to donate vaccine rides - then they sure as hell can take the heat for avoiding pro-social taxes. At a minimum, they should pay that tax savings towards vaccine rides. I won’t hold my breath.
- pstuart 6y agoThat makes it sound like the companies are innocently stumbling upon these opportunities when in fact they're actively lobbying/buying these changes.
- quantified 6y agoYou don’t need to choose one or the other.
- happytoexplain 6y agoWhy not both? Dissatisfaction drives change. Yes, companies are expected to take advantage of legal means of increasing value, but there is a spectrum of behavior between "shrewd" and "immoral" that still falls entirely within "legal", and the individual human beings in the affected society reasonably have opinions about where the line is. When the numbers are too disgusting, it's OK for people to express dissatisfaction with both lawmakers and the company in question, market forces be damned. And let's not forget that the companies frequently play an outsize role in influencing the written laws. The line between "playing the game" and "cheating" is very fuzzy in real world systems.
- rattray 6y ago> Why not both? It's hard to be mad at someone once you realize you'd do the same thing if you were in their shoes. Loopholes like this should be illegal, but their existence ~obligates executives to take advantage of them (fiduciary duty). You'd just be bad at business if you didn't. As someone who wants to be good at business, I can't get mad at the players here – just the game.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ruined 6y ago>It's hard to be mad at someone once you realize you'd do the same thing if you were in their shoes. this is projecting. your comment goes on a bit more like this but i'm not going to quote all of it there has been a cultural failure of some sort that rewards people that think like this, and encourages this kind of behavior. maybe we should expect people, especially people in positions of responsibility, to not loot our lives out from under us
- rattray 6y agoI expect (well, I don't expect, but I WANT) my government to stop it from happening. It's foolish to expect people who are in a position of responsibility _to their shareholders_ to act like they're responsible _to you_. They're not. Close the loopholes, raise the taxes (wealth, cap gains, high-earner income, corporate, etc) and stop vilifying people for making money.
- burkaman 6y agoBecoming a CEO does not magically make your responsibility to society disappear. Shareholders are an additional thing you need to worry about, not the only thing. > stop vilifying people for making money Why? They're doing it in a vile way.
- 6y ago
- wolfretcrap 6y agoI just ask one question: Who do you think politicians have their dinner with? Is it a middle class tax paying person or some rich businessmen friends? Who will get his sympathy? Extrapolate from there.
- rhizome 6y agoWhether you take advantage of those codes in these ways is a question of ethics. Nobody's forcing them to do this, "do it all for the shareholders" isn't a law and shareholder suits for fiduciary mismanagement against executives are basically nonexistent in the US. It's a choice, and it's the choice of assholes.
- wolfretcrap 6y agoThis is if you are a startup founder, it makes sense to accept investment, this brings the tax dodging practises which those people already know about and now it's available to you too
- rhizome 6y agoI've taken to calling it anti-American (or anti-whatever country in which they're minimizing their taxes). How better to tell the world that you don't care about the societies that made your success possible than to refuse to help fund them?
- sneak 6y agoThis seems to presuppose that it is an inherently good thing to maximize tax revenue.
- bitterblotter 6y agonot avoiding taxes = communism
- michaelmrose 6y agoIts an inherently good thing if the parties with most of the money aren't ABLE to also opt out of substantially more of the needed burden than the average person but we live in an imperfect world. When deciding if your tax minimization strategy is a good thing simply ask yourself what would happen if everyone found a way to pay virtually nothing. The obvious thing in that scenario is that society collapses. This is obviously not a good thing. Clearly everyone should try to pay a reasonable share. When your strategy is clearly a contrived misuse of an overly complicated tax code that goes against the spirit if not the letter of the law you should be able to figure out what side of the moral line you are on.
- sneak 6y ago> Clearly everyone should try to pay a reasonable share. That isn't clear to me, because using the government to collect revenue hasn't been demonstrated to be a benefit. This still presupposes that government revenue is inherently beneficial. I think if everyone found a way to pay virtually nothing, the government would collapse. That's not the same thing as society collapsing, society and the government are not coterminous. Tax revenues don't go to "society", they go to the government. It is a logical leap to assume a collapse of society when the government loses funding.
- easytiger 6y agoWhy?
- vishnugupta 6y ago> Shit like this makes my head hurt If you are feeling masochistic then I highly recommend these two books. 1. Moneyland [1] 2. Treasure Islands [2] One can set up corporate structures in a way that will make those looking for the real owner stuck in an infinite loop spread across the globe. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/sep/07/moneyland-oliver-bullough-review https://www.theguardian.com/books/2018/sep/07/moneyland-oliv... [2] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10197857-treasure-islands https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/10197857-treasure-island...