4 ms·
I agree with this. Make up your own new word for the new product. Tufu isn't "bean cheese". People don't need "to be fooled" in order to get them to try high
by mc32 6y ago
I agree with this.
Make up your own new word for the new product. Tufu isn't "bean cheese".
People don't need "to be fooled" in order to get them to try highly processed plant products. Truth in advertising and all that.
If you're selling processed plants or insects, great, market it and label it as such. If it's yummy, people will lap it up.
- mikewhy 6y agoThe literal meaning of tofu is "bean curd".
- mc32 6y agoBut that's not what the English ear hears... and on the other hand, in Chinese Tofu is the reference whereas in English Cheese is the reference object. Moreover, Chinese word creation clobs disconnected words together to make new words. Fire + chicken = Turkey, Fire + Car = Locomotive/Train, Fly + Machine = Aircraft, etc. So this is not out of the ordinary for Chinese word creation.
- elliottkember 6y agoCurd is not cheese
- mikewhy 6y agoTBH I still don't get why cheese is being referenced, I've never heard that comparison. I brought it up because the GP said "tofu is not bean cheese" when that's almost exactly what tofu means.
- jfengel 6y agoCheese is being referenced because it's a natural extension of "You can't call it X if it's not the way we used to do X". If Texas wants to limit the definition of meat, then logically they should be limiting the definition of cheese, milk, and even salt, for that matter. Without that, it looks less like a matter of evenhanded regulatory enforcement or consumer protection, and more like a legislature beholden to a corporation.
- yongjik 6y agoNot sure how curd is called in Chinese, but I think the literal meaning is closer to "rotten beans". https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E8%85%90 https://en.wiktionary.org/wiki/%E8%85%90 - to rot; to decay; to spoil
- trompetenaccoun 6y agoCurd doesn't traditionally exist in (Han) China, as with most other dairy. There's a word for it now (凝乳) but it's not in any relation to tofu. The "fu" in doufu taken by itself does indeed mean rotten. But characters on their own can have very different meanings compared to when used in combination in words. There isn't necessarily a connection, just like in English the word "rotten" doesn't have anything to do with the number 10 that's contained in it. Tofu isn't fermented but made by boiling soy milk and adding a coagulating agent. I was curious and looked it up and that process was described the same way already in Ming Dynasty, so the "rotten" character might just be random and not have any such meaning. It's very common in Chinese that new concepts are expressed with existing characters, because you can't go around making up a new character for everything, no one could ever remember that many characters (bad enough as it is). Often it's just about the sound. For example the characters in the word for cheese (起司) mean "rise" and "manage" when taken on their own. It would be gibberish to read it that way, but every Chinese person knows combined they mean cheese.
- arblomp 6y ago> The bill will also keep companies that produce food from...cell cultures, not slaughtered animals, from using the label “meat,” Do we need to make up a new word for “chunks of bovine muscle tissue” if it wasn’t cut out of a whole-ish cow? Sounds to me like it’s about entrenched farming interests throwing red tape at a perceived threat, not “truth in advertising”. No plant burger or vegan cheeze on the market is nefariously hiding their true identity. They actively market their non-meat-ness, to appeal to their main demographic of meat-avoiders, in big green letters on their packaging. There’s no confusion between their earthy/futurey brand names, versus the old-fashioned-farmer style branding of their slaughtered-animal (their words!) counterparts.
- mc32 6y agoI agree with you on the muscle tissue grown in a lab, if it's more or less the same as bovine tissue from an ex-animal, I think it's fair to call it beef. New synthetic materials though should find their own nouns to use and not coöpt terms with longstanding meanings.
- fmakunbound 6y agoExcept that’s not how language evolves. Good luck with that though.
- bg4 6y agoBeef like product? Worked for cheese wiz.
- jschwartzi 6y agoI guess Texas has finally figured out what Coleco already knew back in the 80's. Warm Dead Bird is a much more accurate name than fried chicken.
- Digory 6y agoI think it makes sense to standardize some word for the difference, especially since you’re talking about a commodity. I imagine cheap meat is going to be qualitatively different than cheap Meetabix or whatever they will call it for some years. “It came from a cow” will impose some kind of minimum quality standard — and it’s not clear that standard will always be met in a non standardized market of bovine cell growers. And the inputs are different. Should an increase in cow meat futures drive up grain prices or plastic clamshell prices?
- jdjdjjs 6y agoI know right?! Like all those people thinking there is butter in peanut butter, beer in root beer, and dogs in hot dogs. Make up your own words for things those words aren’t actually describing!
- mc32 6y agoIndeed. I like my peanut paste and frankfurters myself. Beer, on the other hand, I can understand that. It makes sense to me. On the other hand, we don't eat "chien" in Western culture, but in dire circumstances, so there is low probability of confusion with a hot-dog.
- hoppyhoppy2 6y agoAre "soy milk" and "almond milk" and "oat milk" off-limits, too? Since none of them are actually female mammal secretions, what should we call them instead ?
- stjohnswarts 6y agoWe should also cancel coconut milk even though it's been an expression for hundreds of years. It's only right.
- astura 6y agoI guess milk of magnesia has to go with it too then.
- hoppyhoppy2 6y agoWe might also need to rename the Milky Way galaxy. (Or is it acceptable because it's only milk-Y?)
- underseacables 6y agoSoy, almond, and oat, artificially thickened beverage.
- Ekaros 6y agoThey should be as should butter too. Terms like fat, oil or margarine could be used as well with those.
- hoppyhoppy2 6y agoYou're saying we should rename the popular nut spread (the one that pairs well with jelly) to something like "peanut margarine"?
- Ekaros 6y agoYes. Or "peanut spread", "peanut smooth", "peanut stuff". There are dozens of more honest options.
- ub99 6y agoRight… the primary motivation of Texas lawmakers is that they are concerned about people being fooled… I want to be able to buy non-dairy yogurt and non-dairy mayo. Not “yellow paste” or “white soft creamy desert”. There is nothing wrong with products adapting to new realities and offering alternatives under the same general name. These products are clearly labeled already. The only reason to introduce this legislation is to protect powerful animal product lobbies.
- mc32 6y agoNothing wrong with calling it plant protein. Mayonnaise is just a dressing like thousand island, Russian, ranch and hundreds of others who acquired their own names. Yogurt I'm mildly ok with since basically it just means coagulated milk and also includes the necessary bacteria.
- plntbsd 6y agoHello Mr. Arbitrarily Making Rules! N2mu
- ub99 6y agoI find this discussion fascinating. We are both consumers discussing consumer rights. I - a consumer - want to be able to buy a product I recognize by name, that is also made from specific ingredients that I choose, e.g. almond milk. I don’t need your protection from being “fooled”. You - a consumer - don’t own the ingredients that must be contained in a specific product.
- dariusj18 6y agoLet's let the market decide!
- quantified 6y agoCall it “Houstonnaise”, that’ll show ‘em.
- dragonwriter 6y ago
- igetspam 6y agoThis is stupid. Meat is not solely used to describe the output of slaughter. I'll even help you out: https://www.dictionary.com/browse/meat https://www.dictionary.com/browse/meat We've used "meat" to describe lots of things that we eat for a very long time. This is purely bending the knee to a lobby and hyper regulation of enterprise. It makes sense since that's a core value of republican... wait a second! What's happening? What about free enterprise and not having to do things that go against your personal values in business, like serving The Gays or paying for birth control???? Nobody is fooled. It's called "Beyond Beef," not "Beef." This regulation would make it illegal to label something as "Not Chicken" because lobbyist convinced the state that Texans are too stupid and illiterate to recognize anything but the word "Chicken." Frankly, this law is f'ing insulting. I live in Texas and I know how to read. Full disclosure: I'm not vegan or even vegetarian.
- drewrv 6y ago> Meat is not solely the used to describe the output of slaughter. Reminds me of this bit from an underrated sitcom I binged a while back: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lN4V_tgXuNY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lN4V_tgXuNY I'm surprised the lawmakers didn't try to regulate "tuna steaks" out of existence.
- astura 6y agoWatch out, once someone starts successfully selling prepackaged cauliflower steaks then they'll come to take "steak" away too.
- tablespoon 6y ago> We've used "meat" to describe lots of things that we eat for a very long time. That's not a very good argument. Those other uses are only valid in very specific contexts. If someone ordered "extra meat" for their sandwich, and the restaurant threw in some apple slices (as in meat = "the edible part of anything, as a fruit or nut"), pretty much everyone would find that to be scammy. > Nobody is fooled. It's called "Beyond Beef," not "Beef." Yet. This fake "beef" is currently a trendy novelty product. If/when it becomes cheaper than real beef, I guarantee you that there will be concerted attempts to trick people into buying it. These kinds of naming standards are necessary. For instance the difference between "frozen dairy dessert" and "ice cream" (which as a specific government enforced definition). They're both marketed like ice cream, but if I see the former label, I know not to buy it because it's cost-reduced crap (e.g. they whipped so much air into it it can't be called ice cream anymore).
- david38 6y agoThick tires have a lot of “meat”. Meat does not just mean the muscle fiber of an animal. I wonder how opposed Texas was to what people call “American cheese”, now just called “American” because of the FDA. What about negations? Is it now illegal to call something “fake meat”? What about “I can’t believe it’s not butter”? Is that legal in Texas? The lengths to which Texas politicians will go to protect their masters is crazy.