3 ms·
Arab Israelis are also Semites, and are just as much a target of anti-Israeli attitudes as Israeli Jews. The Palestinian identity is historically bound up with
by zozbot234 6y ago
Arab Israelis are also Semites, and are just as much a target of anti-Israeli attitudes as Israeli Jews. The Palestinian identity is historically bound up with opposition to Israel which has often gone as far as outright hate, e.g. in Palestinian mass-media propaganda and early school education. This is what Israel has to work with, while seeking some sort of durable peace in the region. It's not an easy situation for them.
- ttt0 6y ago> The Palestinian identity is historically bound up with opposition to Israel Yeah, I wonder why is that. It's not like they have any valid reason to be against Israel, like having their land being taken away from them in what is basically a lebensraum, so it's surely has to be just some kind of irrational hatred towards Jews.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- zozbot234 6y ago> having their land being taken away from them in what is basically a lebensraum I will concede that this is a common framing of the facts from the Palestinian side. It's not nearly as easy to describe it as 'neutral' however, or to ascertain with any certainty what counts as any "valid reason" as opposed to "irrational hate".
- Dah00n 6y agoNo, it is a common framing of the facts from all sides except Israeli and pro-israel people. It is lebensraum V2.0
- lucideer 6y agoDescribing it as "a common framing from the Palestinian side" implies that (a) it's a minority view and (b) there are other perspectives. But you have neglected to describe those other perspectives. Do they exist? What other way could one possibly frame this?
- mef51 6y agoI promise you Arab Israelis mostly identify as Palestinian See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_citizens_of_Israel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arab_citizens_of_Israel
- zozbot234 6y agoThe article you link to doesn't claim anything like that.
- amscanne 6y agoDon’t know anything about the claim, but one relevant data point is that Lod, a famously mixed Arab and Jewish city in Israel currently has tensions bubbling over: https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/border-police-officers-diverted-to-lod-amid-violent-protests-667894 https://www.jpost.com/israel-news/border-police-officers-div...
- mef51 6y agoIt's the first sentence: >> According to a 2017 survey by University of Haifa professor Sammy Smooha, 16% of the Arab population prefers the term "Israeli Arab", while the largest and fastest growing proportion prefers "Palestinian in Israel", and 17% prefer "Palestinian Arab"
- scythe 6y ago>The Palestinian identity is historically bound up with opposition to Israel All cultural and ethnic identities are synthetic. Whether we choose to accept a definition of Palestinian identity "in opposition to Israel" or not, we are not simply reading off a list, but creating new language. The area that became Israel and Palestine was partitioned between the Sanjuk of Jerusalem and the Vilayet of Beirut under the Ottomans, and the local and regional cultures and identities formed then were not in opposition to anything. To build a future, we are better off taking the good things from the past, rather than the bad ones.
- vinay427 6y ago> This is what Israel has to work with, while seeking some sort of durable peace in the region. This is a situation prior generations of Israelis created in the midst of Palestinians who preferred not to be evicted and harassed from their homeland. This isn't some impossible situation in which Palestinians instinctively hate Israelis with no specific grievances. Moreover, Israel's idea of "durable peace" as proposed in agreements seems to be highly conditional on keeping the land they occupy, in excess of what is recognized by the Palestinians or even by international agreements.