3 ms·
>we need to fix it so states can't create situations where people stand in line for 8+ hours to vote (Georgia, Arizona). Agreed, but you seem to imply it is th
by salawat 6y ago
>we need to fix it so states can't create situations where people stand in line for 8+ hours to vote (Georgia, Arizona).
Agreed, but you seem to imply it is the Federal Government's job to do it, which I do not think many would agree on, one, and two, kicks the problem up a level.
>we need to eliminate gerrymandering.
We already did. It's illegal. Now go find a judge comfortable with establishing an objective legal test that works in all or most cases to measure gerrymandering. I'll wait. (I kid you not, that's what actually holds it up)
>we should address the electoral college, you shouldn't have more voting power just because you live in Idaho.
You shouldn't be able to dictate who the Chief Executive of the Federal Government is by virtue of your population demographics. The Federal Governmemt is the primary mediator between the States, not People. The formula for the number of Electors derived that the States must fill has been unchanged for centuries, but I also agree that legislative meddling (forcing Electors to Vote the popular vote, and negating the Faithless Elector ) completely nullifies the institution's original purpose (a check against demagoguery).
>we should eliminate FPTP. Nobody should be voting for "the lesser of two evils" they should vote for the candidates they like.
Agreed, you'll still jave a problem in that people will still structure ticketsarou d it.
>we should reform campaign finance. It shouldn't be legal for the rich to buy policy.
Agreed. Donations from legal fictions (Corporations, trusts, etc...) should not be a thing. It just leads to issues.
>we should address misinformation and education. Because what we need is an electorate that is presented with accurate information and has been given the tools to process that information. We don't need an electorate swayed by a popular podcaster spewing misinformation.
You're pissing into the wind. People have that already. The tool has been subverted by the SEO, advertising, and media/publishing industry for their own profit which has caused a downswing in actually constructive politicking since placating reachable audiences is necessarily filtered through editorial audience engineering. I.e. instead of printing/advertising/favoring the Truth, you get this tooling printing/advertising/favoring whatever gets the most clicks, or drives the most revenue. Nevermind the perverse incentives and propaganda hazards created by blindly leaving that sort of thing to a government controlled agency.
- cogman10 6y ago> Agreed, but you seem to imply it is the Federal Government's job to do it, which I do not think many would agree on, one, and two, kicks the problem up a level. When state elected politicians can gerrymander their way into power (see next comment), the only other option is federal enforcement. The voice of the harmed is muted in states doing this shit. In fact, in Georgia in particular they are looking at even more punitive measures to stop voters. Without a federal law, how would this ever change? > We already did. It's illegal. Now go find a judge comfortable with establishing an objective legal test that works in all or most cases to measure gerrymandering. I'll wait. (I kid you not, that's what actually holds it up) You are mistaken, that already went through and the SC ruled that gerrymandering cases are nonjusticiable [1], making it legal under current laws. There needs to be a new federal law in order to make it illegal. > You're pissing into the wind. People have that already. > you get this tooling printing/advertising/favoring whatever gets the most clicks, or drives the most revenue. You say we have this, yet we also have a media standard that allows for blatant lies with few consequences [2]. So long the primary source for "news" is talking heads that legally classify themselves as "entertainment" to skirt legal standards for journalism, we've got a big problem. We have a propaganda problem that needs addressing. I don't have the best solution for it. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rucho_v._Common_Cause https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rucho_v._Common_Cause [2] https://www.npr.org/2020/09/29/917747123/you-literally-cant-believe-the-facts-tucker-carlson-tells-you-so-say-fox-s-lawye https://www.npr.org/2020/09/29/917747123/you-literally-cant-...