3 ms·
If there's one way to turn the political process into a complete reality show, this is it. Why bother arguing based on policy when you know that 40-60% of the e
by paxys 6y ago
If there's one way to turn the political process into a complete reality show, this is it. Why bother arguing based on policy when you know that 40-60% of the electorate won't care and simply vote for whoever is the flashiest?
A much better idea is to get rid of the primary process and implement ranked choice voting instead.
- misiti3780 6y agoIn the US, they dont vote for the flashiest, they vote with their tribe. The percentage of people that are "independent" and "undecided" is minuscule, which is why our choice in 2020 was between a orange-colored crazy "republican" (who was a democrat for most of his life) and a barely sentient milquetoast "democrat"
- pavel_lishin 6y ago> they vote with their tribe The current voters do; we don't necessarily know how people who don't currently vote would behave.
- misiti3780 6y agotrue
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoBiden wasn't "barely sentient." Not only did the guy incredibly well prepared during the campaign and debates, but he would even stop to answer additional questions after the lights were off and the cameras stopped rolling. He's not a great orator and wouldn't have been my first choice (If it were up to me only candidates between 50 and 65 would be allowed to run), but he was better prepared for the job than any candidate since Bush Sr.
- MrRiddle 6y agoClinton received all the questions before the debate, I can assume they got them to Biden as well.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoEven if Trump got the questions, he couldn't have answered any of them because the man was the most incompetent national politician in history, modern or otherwise, but that wasn't what I was replying to, was it? Biden clearly has complete control over his own mental faculties and knows more about running a government than 99% of the politicians in this country.
- misiti3780 6y agoYou don't have to do too much homework at this point to see Biden is fading. He isn't the same man he was 10 years ago. I voted for him, but lets not kid ourselves.
- MisterBastahrd 6y agoYou don't have to do much homework to figure out that "barely sentient" doesn't describe him, either.
- misiti3780 6y agoMaybe that was a bit harsh .... I'll give you that.
- moshmosh 6y agoA lot of apparently-odd behavior during campaigns makes a lot more sense when you realize that GOTV (get out the vote), or suppressing your opponents' vote, can be a more effective use of time and resources than actually trying to sway undecideds, in a (de facto) two-party system like ours. This is also why Hillary's nomination was alarming to anyone with a sense of how almost all Republicans and a lot of blue-collar Dems viewed her (rightly or wrongly—doesn't matter). Her nomination was a huge, free boost to R GOTV and gave the Ds an uphill battle for GOTV on their own side (again, doesn't matter whether that was "fair", it just was).
- organsnyder 6y agoEnough of that "Biden is senile" hogwash. That narrative was pushed by people with a long history of gaslighting, seeking to capitalize on a speech impediment.
- paxys 6y agoThat is exactly what ranked choice voting would fix. If there are 5 democrats, 5 republicans and 5 other parties/independents on the ballot, you can now make a much more informed decision (and have your vote still count) without having to bow down to the extreme voices from either party. The mindset of "I'll just vote D or R down the ballot" is no longer an option.
- misiti3780 6y agoi agree, but it will never happen.
- aussiegreenie 6y ago> a barely sentient milquetoast "democrat" Much to my surprise, the "milquetoast" has had one of the most successful starts to a presidency ever. Whether it is the civil war (uncivil??) within the GOP or the fact everybody underestimates "Sleepy Joe". He has had a great start to his presidency. Any non-Trump candidate would look good just by not tweeting at 3.00am. Sleepy Joe is more effective than Sax-playing Bill or No drama Obama because no one is paying attention. And that is good for America and the world.
- throwaway894345 6y ago> Why bother arguing based on policy when you know that 40-60% of the electorate won't care and simply vote for whoever is the flashiest? I think a strong argument could be made that this is already the case.
- paxys 6y agoIt is, but at least most of the "don't care" demographic is staying at home today. Non-voters and indifferent voters are a large enough bloc that spending your entire campaign budget on targeting just them would ensure a win, and that is eventually what every politician's strategy would become.
- throwaway894345 6y agoThat seems to be the point. Targeting ordinary people with less-extreme views. People who aren't wed to a particular political ideology or who aren't motivated by hatred of their political rivals, but who just want to see their own lives and those of their countrymen improved.
- Talanes 6y agoYou would have a greater point if our current system wasn't based around tricking as much of that 40-60% that doesn't care into showing up anyway.
- r00fus 6y agoYou aren't mentioning the other part (notably more influent part) that systematically prevents people from voting. One removes names from voting rolls using brain-dead software that is 95% inaccurate.
- newacct583 6y ago> Why bother arguing based on policy when you know that 40-60% of the electorate won't care and simply vote for whoever is the flashiest? You say this as if the last administration somehow didn't exist? Analysis of the mobilization power of the Trump campaigns will go on for decades and decades, but among the reasons for his appeal the notion that it was somehow due to consistent and well-explained policy positions has to be dead last. I mean, please.
- gonational 6y agoI agree with your first paragraph. I don't think the solution is to use ranked choices though. I think the solution is to make voting rights contingent on full time work or taxes paid (whether through work or capital gains). As long as you work full time or pay an equivalent in federal taxes of a full-time minimum wage employee (before deductions, because I realize minimum wage employees pay almost no taxes to begin with), you get to vote. You might think this is draconian, but without using any emotion and trying to be purely logical, can you think of one reason why somebody who doesn't pay any taxes or work full-time should have a vote on the government that is funded by tax dollars from other working people? It doesn't mean people who don't work or worthless or should be marginalized in anyway; it means that they don't have a place in the political world, because politics is for government and government is designed to manage people and is paid for by the people who build the society that is being governed. Those who don't want to participate in this society by working have choices, they can stay at home and play video games or they might be a stay at home husband or wife or whatever, or they might just be somebody who wants to sleep in the park, whatever the case, it doesn't mean that they are a worthless human, but they are not really an active participant in the economy being governed. If I'm a stay at home husband and my wife works, my wife gets a vote and I can hopefully attempt to persuade her if I have an opinion, but if I'm not participating in the economy, I don't expect that I should have the ability to make choices about with my wife's taxes are spent on. Of course the exception would be those in retirement who did previously work.
- qsort 6y ago> without using any emotion and trying to be purely logical, can you think of one reason why somebody who doesn't pay any taxes or work full-time should have a vote on the government that is funded by tax dollars from other working people? Yes, I do. Because moving around cash isn't the only thing a modern government does. Governments hold immense power over each and every citizen, and as such, each and every citizen should have a say in how governments are run. TLDR: If you can send me to fight in a war, you'd better have me have a say in the decision.
- dagw 6y agoOnce you start making voting conditional on being part of a certain class then the then people in power will start making sure that the people who disagree with them end up in the class that isn't allowed to vote.