3 ms·
I'm fine with compulsory voting if there is a "none of the above" ballot option that abolishes the position in the government for that term. Otherwise it's jus
by sneak 6y ago
I'm fine with compulsory voting if there is a "none of the above" ballot option that abolishes the position in the government for that term.
Otherwise it's just compelled speech, and fuck that.
- cl0ckt0wer 6y agoAbdicating responsibility doesn't mean things will get better. Just that someone else will make the decision for you.
- crmrc114 6y agoIf both candidates fail to represent me, why should I reward either one with a vote? Sometimes both sides can be equally contestable. I know with all the get out to vote propaganda in the United States we're all told that we should participate. But if the system is inherently broken, I can act much more change personally on a local level with local elections and state elections. I think a lot of people are in the same boat as me and we write off the federal government as a circus where the highest funded candidate gets into office. (On that note, if we banned corporate donors, that would be a very interesting experiment)
- sneak 6y agoNot my circus, not my monkeys. It's not an abdication of responsibility, as I don't recognize the responsibility or the authority of mob rule in the first place. You're right that it means someone else will make the decision for me, and it will be enforced against me with violence. I'd rather not participate in it at all, because that gives the whole process the appearance of consent and legitimacy. I don't actually think democracy is a good way to run things, and I don't consent to the application of it to me, or the demand that I participate in it, or the insinuation that I have some responsibility to do so. I never signed up for this and don't want it. My participation is implied/tacit acceptance of the outcome even if it is different from my vote, and no such acceptance exists.
- r00fus 6y agoThere is a "none of the above" - it's called a write-in. You can write-in a blank. Instead of none of the above, maybe you mean a vote of "no confidence"?
- bawolff 6y agoThat depends on your country. Write ins are kind of a crazy idea pragmatically. I cant imagine most countries have them. Mine (canada) certainly doesnt. You can always spoil your ballot or give a blank ballot.
- crmrc114 6y agoIf I recall correctly, some states would actually throw out or invalidate your entire ballot if you do a write in. If memory serves Oklahoma was one of them.
- sneak 6y agoHow's that work in a system of compulsory voting, the topic at hand? How is making me go to the ballot box to fill in "blank" any different than letting me stay home?
- r00fus 6y agoYou are recorded making a no-choice. In the US, you have multiple elections on each per ballot card (ostensibly to reduce cost of running the election), so you'd have to no-choice all the ballot entries if you were to simulate not voting at all. ie, making it as difficult to not vote as it is to vote (unless you want to risk consequences of law).
- crmrc114 6y agoI think a better option would be if I could rate candidates on a scale of 1 to 10. There's some interesting research on these voting systems, if one of my candidates has no chance of winning my next best candidate will get my vote. it would be an interesting system to see in practice. Edit, link; https://electionscience.org/library/score-voting/ https://electionscience.org/library/score-voting/
- alistairSH 6y agoThis. Almost any flavor of preference voting would be an improvement of our current single-ballot plurality system. You don't even have to rate the choices to see an improvement. Just pick any that are acceptable. Ballot design stays almost exactly the same. No run-off needed. Easy to understand. In US presidential elections, that might mean somebody gets to vote R and L. Or D and G. Or D, G, and L. Etc.