3 ms·
Actually, there may be a few reasons why legacy truck manufacturers are pushing this agenda: 1) They've been pushing it for a long time and have already invest
by jillesvangurp 6y ago
Actually, there may be a few reasons why legacy truck manufacturers are pushing this agenda:
1) They've been pushing it for a long time and have already invested a lot. Most of that investment is going to have to be written off unless they find a use for all the hydrogen R&D. I note that it is mainly legacy manufacturers pushing this whereas battery operated trucks have a fair amount of startups in advanced stages of getting their trucks, buses, heavy mining vehicles etc. on the road.
2) Hydrogen trucks and their designs are a lot more similar to current trucks then battery electric ones. These manufacturers have a vested interest in their legacy production facilities and supply lines and milking that investment as long as possible is a goal for them. Their real goal is exactly that: keeping the infrastructure that produces Diesel trucks going for a few extra years. That's also the elephant in the room: their operational cost of hydrogen trucks is going to be much higher than battery electric trucks; or even Diesel trucks. The fuel cost is higher and they have about the same complexity as Diesel trucks.
3) There is a lot of government money flowing into the hydrogen sector and getting in on that action is interesting for big companies. Given future availability of this stuff, and the subsidies, there is going to be a market for trucks that run on it. Even if it is tiny, it might still be interesting. Unless of course battery trucks take off and destroy the business case for this. Like happened to hydrogen cars.
Storing 1Mwh of electricity might actually be pretty fast and not necessarily a lot slower than charging a normal EV. A battery contains numerous cells that you charge at the same time. All it takes is a lot of power and temperature control (and thick cables).
The answer to how fast or how slow this will be is more or less a function of how much speed is worth to a trucking company. Idling trucks and drivers cost money. But then trucks needing regular maintenance are also idling. And drivers need to take breaks regardless of whether their trucks need charging. And drivers might ultimately no longer be needed if trucks become autonomous.
People pay for getting stuff from A to B. The rest is just a means to an end. Trucking cleanly, cheaply, and reliably is what matters. Cost per mile basically. There is a notion of good enough here. E.g. having lots of charging stations and trucks that charge to a reasonable percentage in say 45 minutes might mean that a 45 minute break every 6 hours or so might not be the end of the world for a lot of drivers and trucking companies. Entirely feasible with current battery technology. Tesla is basically pimping 500 mile ranges. That's more like a break every 10-12 hours or so. I imagine that, charging times, and cost per mile might improve quite a bit in the next ten years. Tesla is starting production end of this year apparently. And they are not alone in the market.
Getting that break time down might of course be worth something to someone. But the question is how much that is and whether it justifies more complicated and more expensive technology like hydrogen. I suspect not a lot and just no.