5 ms·
I read HN from google reader. And it tells me that someone had just liked this news. The freedom of China's intranet needs to be fought for by its own people.
by yicai 15y ago
I read HN from google reader. And it tells me that someone had just liked this news.
The freedom of China's intranet needs to be fought for by its own people. But how could anyone `like' current situation like this?
- jasonlotito 15y agoThey like the post alerting people to this fact. The like it to share it with more people, making them aware. They aren't liking that China is doing this. Liking that something is posted is not the same as liking the news.
- c1sc0 15y agoSomeone who agrees that maintaining the current 'social stability' in China outweighs the benefits brought by yet-another-social-network.
- Retric 15y agoYou need to also assume that filtering the web increases 'social stability'. For many young people in China the amount of government interference with the web is literally their number one complaint.
- bilbo0s 15y agoUhhh...what? Try 'working conditions'...or actually...try 'just getting a job'. You must know some super rich Chinese young people if their number one complaint is Google access.
- Retric 15y agoBy young think 15 not 25. The problem is not so much they are going to create a revolution today, rather the government is poisoning the well by eroding peoples trust.
- nextparadigms 15y agoThat's what all the dictators say. "We need to maintain stability, so keep doing what we tell you. Don't you dare even question us - for the sake of our society, of course."
- yaix 15y agoActually, its the other way around. Don't even dare to mention stability or you get lynched in the West. Ask people in Rhuanda/Burundi what happened when their dictator president got shot down. Or in Somalia. Or how the real situation in Iraq or Afghanistan is. Sometimes stability actually is paramount. It's even empirically measurable and relates to average household income. But I don't want to bore you with science on the topic. There are many books and papers on the topic. And its not just theory, I am living in developing and "unfree" countries for many years to see the practical part as well. Stuff's not just "black and white" -- there is a lot more to it. But that wasn't the topic of this debate anyways.
- william42 15y agoOut of curiosity, can you link to the science on the topic?
- yaix 15y agoA few good reads on the topic are F. Fukuyama "Trust: Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity" and P. Collier "The bottom Billion" and "Wars, Guns and Votes: Democracy in Dangerous Places".
- blake8086 15y agoThis also seems just patently obvious: why would you bother trying to create wealth if someone is likely to come along and steal it from you?
- pohl 15y ago"like" is just a marketing label for the button/link. The actual function of it is to increase the visibility of the story. A lot of people have figured this out and use the facility for what it does rather than how it is labeled. I see this on FB a lot, too.