2 ms·
> Documents are the quintessential use case for the Web, full stop In 1996, yes. And you can still use the Web that way. Nobody's stopping you. Much of the Web
by vkou 6y ago
> Documents are the quintessential use case for the Web, full stop
In 1996, yes. And you can still use the Web that way. Nobody's stopping you. Much of the Web is still used that way, and that's not going to change.
But in 2021, the web serves documents, and applications. And HTML/CSS was never intended as a way to build applications.
It's why people came up with Flash, Java Applets, ActiveX, and all that other shit. And the web today wouldn't be one whit better off if the vendors of those technologies took your advice, and rolled their functionality into the core web. In fact, it would be in many, many ways worse off.
- pwdisswordfish8 6y agoThis is not a response to the point being made at the point where the quoted text originates, even though superficially it looks like it is. Please re-read the comment you're responding to.
- vkou 6y agoActually, it responds to the entire[1] train of thought that follows that statement. Please re-read what I am saying, and consider it in context. You are suggesting that Google work on updating the standards to make their desired use case work better. I am suggesting that Google's desired use case will never be served by document-oriented standards, and that is why it shouldn't mess with those standards. Again, the world would not be better off if ActiveX were rolled into web standards back in the oughts. Leave document standards responsible for displaying documents, and don't let the needs of application people get in the way of that. [1] Well, I don't respond to your point that Google Docs is intended to display documents - because, as another commenter points out, it's incredibly obvious that its most important function is to edit documents.