6 ms·
Same here, I'm in a ~90K town on the outskirts of the Bay Area, and there is a proposal to build a handful of "affordable apartments" in the downtown area. I ge
by ryandrake 6y ago
Same here, I'm in a ~90K town on the outskirts of the Bay Area, and there is a proposal to build a handful of "affordable apartments" in the downtown area. I get the feeling that most people are apathetic, maybe slightly for it, since more housing is probably, in the balance, good for the Bay Area. But, man, the few people against it are really against it, they are organized, retired (so they have infinite time to fight it), have seemingly infinite funds, and are really, really angry. If you just looked at the surface, you'd think it was a huge angry mob. But, it's actually the same tiny group of people writing their letters to the local paper and attending the council meetings over and over. They are very good at projecting strength and amplifying their message through various media. If I was actually passionate about building affordable housing, I would definitely burn out and get cynical, having to face this every time.
It works exactly like this all the way up from local through to federal politics. We Can't Have Nice Things in democracies, because of a small number of people willing to commit their entire souls, lives and money to some niche cause that's a net-bad, and they won't quit, even after losing 50 times. All it takes is that 51st time, and they'll definitely be at the fight.
- mikem170 6y ago> But, it's actually the same tiny group of people writing their letters to the local paper and attending the council meetings over and over. > We Can't Have Nice Things in democracies, because of a small number of people I wonder if this is more a problem with representational government. In a democracy there would be no council to influence, instead everyone would have an equal vote on the issue.
- dbingham 6y agoI think it would still be a problem, but a lesser one. A loud minority can still influence a majority. But it's harder. The thing with direct democracy is that we'd really need to implement like a 20 hour work week to make it work. Everyone would need to find the time to get up to date on all of the issues. Or you'd end up with a minority of people who happen to know and care about each issue controlling that issue... which maybe that's okay, actually. It would be really interesting to see how a true direct democracy behaved at the government level. I've seen it work at the level of a workplace or a housing cooperative. And it does work, it's effortful, but it works. But I dunno if it's ever really been tried at the level of a government.
- mprovost 6y agoAn option that Kim Stanley Robinson explored is his novels is a kind of draft/jury service model where voters are randomly selected to serve in government. Sometimes for a whole term, but you can also imagine something like jury service where a group is brought together to decide a single issue. They would have the time to hear both sides of the arguments, make a decision, and then disband.
- bobthepanda 6y agoThis is actually how Athenian democracy worked. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Athenian_democracy#Selection_by_lot https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Athenian_democracy#Selection...
- watwut 6y agoYes, but the citizens were only subset of population and the city was smaller then current states. It is quite possible that it would not scale to larger population and general voting rights.
- bobthepanda 6y agoSure, I was just addressing my parent comment's proposal and providing more context. I don't really care for it, although I will have to say it would probably work better in the case of opaque public bodies very few people vote for elections in (e.g. a local American school board)
- oftenwrong 6y agoThere is a candidate for mayor in NYC that is running on a direct democracy platform: https://www.seidmanformayor.com/ https://www.seidmanformayor.com/
- rrrrrrrrrrrryan 6y agoLiquid Democracy is a quirky concept that would probably resolve the problem you're describing. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_democracy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liquid_democracy
- thaumasiotes 6y agoCounterargument: the problem is not the form of the government. Rather, the problem is that the government has a say in whether you can personally construct a building on "your own" land.
- mikem170 6y agoMy comment was more directed towards the generic problem of a small (loud? rich?) minority having undue influence over the local representatives who decide on issues. I personally would tend to agree with you on the specific issue we were talking about. I'm personally a fan of the way Japan does zoning, which allows for growth (more height and more retail) when the population density grows (industrial separate). The documentation I had showed that the Swiss set the principals for zoning at a federal level, and zoning is actually administered at the most local municipality level. I'm not sure of the Swiss implementation details. But in my ideal world that would mean a Japanese style zoning principals at the federal level, administered locally. A municipality can decide where they want industrial areas, and how to tax for their infrastructure, but local NIMBYs would have no power over what can be built on a specific plot (the federal principals would control that).
- bluGill 6y agoIt is worse in a democracy. In a representative system you only need to find one person who shows up for a bunch of like minded people. In a democracy you personally need to show up every meeting not matter what else might go on in your life. There are some small town democracies where the meeting starts, does good business, but nobody will agree to adjourn for the night, when the people with things to do the next day go home the remainder just revote everything that happened earlier in the night, this time getting it to go their way. As a resident you have to stay the whole meeting to stop that - even if it means you will be fired for falling asleep at work the next day.
- mikem170 6y agoIn a democracy everyone needs to vote. Which can be at the polls. Why do you assume that everyone needs to sit in on every legislative session? It could be that way, but I don't see where it has to be. There's a lot of ways to be democratic. For example, perhaps our block elects a representative to attend council meetings, who will inform our group on issues in front of council, maybe someone else contributes with some extra research, etc, then we decide how our block will vote in council. Just one of many possibilities.
- bluGill 6y agoThe devil is in the details. The only democracies I know of are in person meetings, though you are correct there are other ways. The problem is how to get people to think about the issues? Too many fail to realize the unintended consequences of their vote. Too many vote for what they think is popular not what is right.
- mountainboy 6y agoA democracy is two wolves and a chicken deciding what to eat for dinner.