5 ms·
> Care about our national housing shortage? In nearly every city there exists a small angry mob that works to block every development project, and this job tend
by nerdponx 6y ago
> Care about our national housing shortage? In nearly every city there exists a small angry mob that works to block every development project, and this job tends to be loudest and angriest about middle to low income housing and apartments.
Somewhat tangential story, but I thought it was interesting in this context.
A former landlord in NYC told me a story where some local community board was required to approve a new 3-story apartment building with some kind of public/community space on the first floor, which was replacing a couple old 2-family homes.
There were two groups in opposition: the "old white men" who own property in the area, and the young DSA board members who stuck to their hard line of "no new development". Apparently the old white men didn't always get their way in the past, but their new coalition with the hipster socialists was enough to block the development.
Said landlord had lived in the area for ~40 years so he was pretty annoyed at the blockage of what he saw as necessary and beneficial development, that (IMO) was also perfectly in-character with the area. Then again, the same landlord was strongly in favor of the Amazon deal in Long Island City.
Axiom: "all politics are local". Theorem: "local politics are more important than you think". Corollary: "if you care about improving other people's lives, get involved in local politics".
- alistairSH 6y agoWhy were the young liberals against an apartment building? That sounds way out of character, unless what they really wanted was an even taller (and more affordable) apartment building.
- fossuser 6y agoSee this: https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/the-left-nimby-canon https://noahpinion.substack.com/p/the-left-nimby-canon There’s a new form of NIMBYism that’s pretty extreme and comes from the left. The only group interested in building housing seems to be the neoliberals/moderates/center - people that believe in markets/supply and demand? The politics around this stuff is a mess. I wish there was just a way to incentivize building.
- alistairSH 6y agoThanks! I wasn't thinking of opposition to gentrification/displacement. We hear similar arguments in DC, but they tend to come from current residents, who are often Black or other PoC, and not traditional (young, white) liberals. Related anecdote: After gentrification, DC gets some interesting side-effects... there are several "neighborhood" churches where most of the congregants live 30+ minutes away in the suburbs, due to being priced out of the local rental market. And these church-goers do everything in their power to block bicycle lanes downtown, because they need the street-side parking for the church.
- EricE 6y ago"gentrification" is just a way for people to be NIMBY while feeling noble at the same time. It would be pretty freaking hilarious if it didn't harm so many people - especially those at the lower end of the housing spectrum. It's the ultimate in selfishness "I'm secure with my affordable housing - screw everyone else" :p Two things can be true at the same time - you can be economically disadvantaged and also be a selfish asshole too. I'm so sick of people giving groups a total pass on not being toxic, selfish assholes because they also are also part of a "protected" class.
- alistairSH 6y agoI didn't give anybody a pass. :shrug:
- dang 6y agoCan you please not post in the flamewar style to HN? We're trying for a different sort of conversation here. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- fossuser 6y agoI don’t think it’s the building that creates gentrification - it’s the lack of supply. Increasing supply to meet demand should reduce prices. Not building to keep housing crappy enough to reduce demand doesn’t work (and doesn’t everyone prefer to live in a nicer place?). If that fails they fall back on generic environment arguments, “taking down any building is bad for the environment”. I think it’s all just status quo bias and resistance to change, resistance to building. All of the arguments that come after that are driven entirely by motivated reasoning. If you lean left it’s the left nimby canon, if you lean right it’s the right version of that. I just want more housing supply.
- nerdponx 6y agoFor what it's worth, they'd chafe at the term "liberal". I think their idea is that development inevitably means gentrification, so they are opposed to development in order to stop the advance of gentrification.
- Taylor_OD 6y agoA few years ago (pre trump election) I took an uber with a driver who was very engaged in politics. I cared a lot at the time and we had an interesting discussion about national politics. Then I asked him about Chicago and Illinois politics (where we were) and he said he didn't follow local politics. I was shocked. While Trump getting elected certainly impacted that persons life, their actual ability to make change in their community would be far more impactful if they focused on the local level. But local politics do not provide as much fun political us vs them talk which is what it feel like most people actually enjoy about politics.
- EricE 6y agoThe focus on national politics by the media and both parties is the greatest scam perpetuated by an (unfortunately) all too willing populace. As the old saying goes, All politics are local. And the last four years in particular have been a huge wake up call to me that I need to get WAY more interested and involved in local politics. Utter BS like critical race theory would never get a toe hold in our schools, for example, if people paid attention at all to what was going on in their literal back yard. In one way COVID and kids attending school remotely has been hugely beneficial in that a lot of people have started to pick up on the utter garbage being routinely foisted on our kids.
- andorxor 6y agoSome things really can't be changed on the local level. Take forced arbitration in contracts for example. This was made possible by a federal law passed in the 1920's, and further cemented by a series of supreme court rulings in the past couple of decades. No amount of desire or political will by individual states can ban the practice. The federal law trumps all, and this must be changed at the national level.
- Taylor_OD 6y agoSure. There are a large number of items that are national law that can have great change. But the average persons ability to impact those things is very very very small. The average persons ability to impact their own local politics and make change is much much much larger than many think.