4 ms·
Ok, emotional me really hated this site, so rational me will try to calm down a bit and explain why. I started with the "Dislikes about email are Questionable"
by hn_throwaway_99 6y ago
Ok, emotional me really hated this site, so rational me will try to calm down a bit and explain why.
I started with the "Dislikes about email are Questionable" post, which was perhaps my mistake, but every point in that post had a dripping "I'm sorry peasant, you're doing it wrong" vibe to it.
I can fully understand why someone may choose to use email over other forms of communication, but to be incredibly dismissive of problems other people have with the medium, while furthermore often not even addressing some of the root frustrations people have, is incredibly condescending.
Take the "email is unreliable" point. You can write all the missives you want about how email is the most reliable form of communication known to man, at the end of the day a huge number of messages can get "sent" which never make it to the intended recipient for a myriad of reasons. And furthermore, pretty much everyone has had an experience where this has happened.
- nikisweeting 6y agoI started with that post as well, and had a similar reaction. Also I find it misses most of the real points against email and focuses on the relatively minor ones. - email enforces much higher latency communication, which maybe good sometimes, but most of the time is not helpful - much more difficult to actually keep track of a threaded conversation with multiple concurrent subtrees, it's a stack when instead you want a tree like Zulip / Slack threads. quote replying a subthread in an email tree without disrupting convos in the rest is a painful experience even in the nicest clients. - file attachment and embed preview experience is worse than most modern IM apps - no emoji reactions, these are huge for efficient async communication without spamming everyone with notifications