4 ms·
There is a site just across the SF border, in Daly City, over by Lake Merced (which is in SF) where there are markers for the Broderick-Terry duel[1]. The site
by mc32 6y ago
There is a site just across the SF border, in Daly City, over by Lake Merced (which is in SF) where there are markers for the Broderick-Terry duel[1]. The site is unremarkable, but nice and quiet[2].
[1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broderick%E2%80%93Terry_duel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Broderick%E2%80%93Terry_duel
[2]https://www.google.com/maps/place/Broderick-Terry+Duel+Site/@37.7080262,-122.4861629,17z https://www.google.com/maps/place/Broderick-Terry+Duel+Site/...
- casefields 6y agoThat's neat. I would love to return to duels for Congress. Just look at this gerontocracy: Among congressmen 80 and over, 9 are Democrats and 2 are Republicans Among congressmen 70 and over, 57 are Democrats and 19 are Republicans Among senators 80 and over, 2 are Democrats and 3 are Republicans Among senators 70 and over, 18 are Democrats and 7 are Republicans Among senators 60 and over, 34 are Democrats and 28 are Republicans If McConnell and Schumer hate either other that much, they should have PPV duel with the proceeds to going some charity. If that's too grisly for folks maybe allow mutual combat. Remember when Biden told that voter to if he wanted to step outside and settle it? https://www.commondreams.org/news/2020/03/10/you-wanna-go-outside-me-joe-biden-tries-fight-union-worker-after-disagreement-over https://www.commondreams.org/news/2020/03/10/you-wanna-go-ou... Hell yeah I would've loved that.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoAt those ages, they might run out of ammo before either of them hit the other.
- betwixthewires 6y agoStep outside and settle it is one thing. But we don't duel anymore because it is honestly pretty messed up. There's a whole lot of perverse incentives that come to mind, and the institution created a whole host of social problems. Imagine you're drinking beer with a buddy and someone you don't like comes up, and you say "yeah that guy is a total chode." He gets wind of it, is aghast and offended, and publicly challenges you to a competition where you try to shoot each other to death. You say no, and you're now a dishonorable coward and are never getting the company of a lady again, or any position of respect or business from many of your peers. You have to say yes, and kill someone or die or get grisly wounded for life. People romanticize it, but I wouldn't want to live in a society where I have to kill people or die over petty squabbles.
- sellyme 6y ago> People romanticize it You're clearly talking to different people than I am.
- mc32 6y agoI agree it’s not the way to settle scores in today’s society (though it’s still this way in ganglands, be they mafia or LA gangs). That said, it wasn’t an everyday thing, and given the dire consequences it wasn’t something done lightly out of the blue yonder. People knew not to offend or risk the possibility. And for the most part this was ritual for the upper classes and not for the village boors or even commoners.
- joshuahedlund 6y ago> People romanticize it, but I wouldn't want to live in a society where I have to kill people or die over petty squabbles. In a lot of inner city American neighborhoods today people do live like this. And it’s pretty horrid for the kids growing up in it.
- spankyspangler 6y ago> Step outside and settle it is one thing. What one thing, hateful toxic masculinity and bullying from a white male in a position of power and privilege? You're saying that like it is not also "honestly pretty messed up".
- KMag 6y agoI only remember once being challenged to a fight outside. I didn't find it difficult to turn down. Biden surely shouldn't have used a threat of violence, but, especially in context, I doubt the recipient took the threat literally. The OP's point is that it's a difference in kind, not of degree. For the record, toxic masculinity is bad, and a power differential makes it worse. Toxic masculinity coming from Kamala would have been just as bad. It's the power, regardless of source, that makes the toxicity more destructive. (A friend and I had a code word for if either of us thought we had gotten into a bad situation. She had been flirting with a really drunk guy in a bar, not really interested, just liked the attention. The guy started following her around the bar. I wasn't sure if she was playing hard to get, until she got into a corner and started shouting our code word, which just confused the guy. I put my hand on the guy's shoulder and suggested he give her some room, at which point he suggested he and I take a step outside. A simple "nah, I think I'm fine" was sufficient to avoid a fight, but didn't really calm him down. The only time I used our code word was when we were vacationing in a developing country, had both gotten drunk, and some people we met invited us to a restaurant for some sober-up food. The restaurant didn't have a restroom, and one of the guys clearly took me a long twisting way to a restroom and promised to wait for me outside. 30 seconds later, my guide was nowhere to be found. I ran back, the short way, to the restaurant to find my guide and the others pressuring my friend to do some shots. I told her our code word and we left some money on the table for a couple shots and walked as fast as we could back to the main tourist strip.)
- krrrh 6y agoI ran the same analysis a while back and was really surprised how short team blue’s bench is compared to team red.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]