2 ms·
At some point in the 80's or 90's I read a book by someone who was at AT&T and into simulating room dynamics. One thing I remember is that, according to him, a
by 082349872349872 6y ago
At some point in the 80's or 90's I read a book by someone who was at AT&T and into simulating room dynamics.
One thing I remember is that, according to him, a large amount of classical music sounds much better when the transfer function approximates a relatively tall, narrow room (like a cathedral) than when it approximates a relatively short, wide room (like a modern concert hall).
(note that construction spans, lighting, and ventilation, all conspire to make historical rooms taller and narrower than our typical rooms)
- Slow_Hand 6y agoWell I don't know what the writer's exact reasoning is, but there are few factors for why larger rooms are favorable: 1) Room modes. Small rooms are far more destructive because they feature hot-spots where the sound waves (especially the low end) are either cancelled out or reinforced in a way that makes them too loud. Large ceilings and lots of the depth to the room give the low frequencies space to propagate completely and a more even frequency response that isn't lumpy or lacking when you stand in certain parts of the room. 2) Reverberation. Pretty obvious, but the average length of the echoes/reverberant tail increase as the room gets bigger. This is gives an ambient quality to the sound that is well suited to orchestral ensembles. You could probably argue that the history of orchestral composition grew in tandem with this quality and informed the choices that were made or play best with the qualities of a room large enough to house an orchestra and audience. That said, highly percussive music might be muddied or hard to articulate cleanly if it's fighting against a massive reverb tail in a cathedral.