4 ms·
When I have visited the US I have been mystified by the way sales taxes work. The prices on labels exclude tax, but the percentage changes depending on where I
by lostlogin 6y ago
When I have visited the US I have been mystified by the way sales taxes work. The prices on labels exclude tax, but the percentage changes depending on where I go (or what I buy?).
It surprises me that residents tolerate that.
“How much is it?” would seem a simple question.
- visualradio 6y agoA move towards making sales taxes less transparent in the United States is unlikely, because many U.S. founders associated with the Democratic-Republican party such as James Madison were influenced by the French Physiocratic school economics, which considered broad-based sales taxes to be a quite harmful method of taxation that should never be relied on as a permanent source of revenue. This opinion is most clearly expressed by Joel Barlow in "Letters Addressed to the Yeomanry of the United States: Showing the Necessity of Confining the Public Revenue to a Fixed Proportion of the Net Produce of the Land; and the Bad Policy and Injustice of Every Species of Indirect Taxation and Commercial Regulation" (1791).
- lostlogin 6y ago> broad-based sales taxes That an interesting history, thanks. The policy sort of misses the point when you are at the till and the item doesn’t cost what you thought it did. There is no way of telling if you have been hit by a broad-based sales tax, a targeted one or both.
- californical 6y agoThis is a really interesting point and got me thinking — if taxes were hidden, people wouldn’t directly notice the cost increases associated with raising sales tax. If you pay $1.12 for a $1.00 soda in city one, but $1.07 in city two, you will directly realize the tax impact that the local sales tax has. I wonder if this was originally intentional, to prevent taxes from invisibly rising without the people being aware of the impact of the price. It also makes it much harder for national brands if they like to have nice round numbers as the cost of things (which they seem to) - they can’t charge $1.00 for a soda everywhere, or their margins would be crazy wonky depending on region
- johncessna 6y agoAmericans in the states that haves sales tax, which is most states, basically ignore it. It's known that the price tag isn't what you pay but it's generally not much. No one here looks twice when your 2 dollar coke suddenly becomes $2.16. Of course, depending on where you are, your 2.16 coke could also jump up to 2.21 or 2.26 because of the bottle deposit. And then another 2.34-2.42 if there's a sugar tax. It could even go up to 2.46 - 2.54 depending on if you buy that coke in a store vs a restaurant. There's some hyperbole there, but the cities and states get to tack on their own taxes for whatever reason and the public largely doesn't care.
- xur17 6y agoThat said, it makes me really hate paying with cash (because then I have to deal with a lot of random change).
- smegger001 6y agoOh they care, A few years ago WA instituted at sugar sin tax on candy and soda, and it was rapidly repealed by ballot initiative the same year. It didn't help that the definition of what was considered candy was extremely arbitrary. (the rule of thumb was if it contained any flour it wasn't "candy". so a Twix or Kitkat wasn't candy but Payday was) Then there was New York Soda size cap that was almost immediate overturned in court challenges before it could even take affect.
- bobthepanda 6y agoMessaging and targeting are very important. Taxes make a pack of cigarettes $12 in NY but this was done slowly over time. And the loud protests have turned into teeny grumbles. Though it also helped that Mike Bloomberg is not a man Big Tobacco can buy, given the fact that he is one of the richest men in town already, in a very wealthy town.
- coryrc 6y agoDepends, if I get something delivered, the sales tax can be based on my home, but if I pick it up it's based on the seller's location.
- Mountain_Skies 6y agoLocal sales taxes are some of the easiest to get passed. Even in very conservative areas they tend to get passed and renewed. They are popular because the public gets to vote on them existing and because it's much easier to see how the taxes are being spent. I live in a conservative area right now and can't remember a local sales tax ever being voted down. The only case I can think of was when I lived in the middle of a large city (very left leaning) and the local sales tax was voted down because the politicians pushing for it had not said exactly what it would be spent on other than "special projects". They had previously diverted a good chunk of property tax revenues to building a new sport stadium because the billionaire owner was threatening to move the team to another state. The public wasn't given an opportunity to vote on that gift of their taxes to a billionaire so there probably was both mistrust and a degree of blowback. Other than that case, local sales taxes, dedicated to a local purpose or project list, are popular here. If the sales taxes all went to DC to be piled together and subject to the whims of whatever party was in charge at the time, they'd be far less popular. Asking locals to pay an extra 1% to renovate and expand the local schools is pretty easy. Asking the entire country to pay an extra 1% to "Make American Schools Great Again" is a much more difficult sell.
- curryst 6y agoI strongly suspect that part of the reason sales taxes are easy to pass is because it's really hard to convert that into a dollar amount that you'll end up paying. For income tax, you can ballpark it by just multiplying your income by the percentage increase. If you want a better answer, you need to see how much of your income falls into the affected brackets, but you can still get an answer in 15 minutes or so. It's really hard to figure out how many more dollars I'm going to pay in taxes if the sales tax goes up 1%. I have to figure out how much money I spend on goods that have sales tax. Okay, so I put $X in my savings account which isn't taxed, and I pay $Y in rent, which means I'm spending $Z on other stuff. Oh right, but not all of that has sales tax, so I have to take that stuff out. It gets complicated, fast, and the best you're going to get is an estimate. If any of those numbers change, my sales tax burden changes. Plus sales tax is deferred until you spend the money, so there's no immediate obvious impact. It's not like you have less money than you did last year, although your spending power does go down every so slightly. Income taxes are unpopular to adjust because it's easy to see how much you're losing, and it directly impacts your paychecks, which people don't like.
- timonoko 6y agoThey have tried to introduce this practice to European countries several times. People just refused to accept that the real price is something else than advertised. I distinctly remember I was buying rather pricey welding machine in 1995 and it was suddenly +25% "with tax". I have never moved so fast, I just left every piece of shit on the checkout desk and run out.