4 ms·

Another Source - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-11/facebook-ordered-to-stop-collecting-german-whatsapp-users-data https://www.bloomberg.com/new

Another Source - https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-11/facebook-ordered-to-stop-collecting-german-whatsapp-users-data https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-05-11/facebook-... > Johannes Caspar, who heads Hamburg’s privacy authority, issued a three-month emergency ban, prohibiting Facebook from continuing with the data collection. He also asked a panel of European Union data regulators to take action and issue a ruling across the 27-nation bloc. The new WhatsApp terms enabling the data scoop are invalid because they are intransparent, inconsistent and overly broad, he said.

humanlion87 5y ago
> Facebook’s WhatsApp unit called Caspar’s claims “wrong” and said the order won’t stop the roll-out of the new terms. I don't understand how Facebook says this order will not stop the roll-out. Are they implying that the authority has no power to implement/enforce the ban?
- Jonanin 5y ago
  They incorrectly assumed (like much of the media) that this update was about sharing data of personal messages with Facebook, when it is in fact not.
  - zwaps 5y ago
    It is, but not yet in the EU. It literally says : we will share everything with Facebook as soon as the EU allows. Right now we do not. But we might. I mean it’s written there.
    - tpush 5y ago
      Where does it literally say that?
      - zwaps 5y ago
        I quote from their website ——— Today, WhatsApp does not share your personal information with Facebook to improve your Facebook product experiences or provide you more relevant Facebook ad experiences on Facebook. This is a result of discussions with the Irish Data Protection Commission and other Data Protection Authorities in Europe. We're always working on new ways to improve how you experience WhatsApp and the other Facebook Company Products you use. Should we choose to share such data with the Facebook Companies for this purpose in the future, we will only do so when we reach an understanding with the Irish Data Protection Commission on a future mechanism to enable such use. We'll keep you updated on new experiences we offer and our information practices. —————— This is legalese for pretty much what I posted. In particular, the keep you update here does not necessarily mean you get to agree to a new privacy policy, as the current policy does not include a commitment not to share data (for ads etc) with facebook in the first place. This statement is deviously placed outside the privacy policy! Also further up they say that they associate the whatsapp profile with any facebook profile in the household/net/vicinity. To be clear, they do this now. Not in the future.
        zwaps 5y ago
        Oh just on case you are unsure what will happen with all this, it’s the following: In the near future, they will start sharing all that juicy data with facebook based on some made up precedent, new technical justification, some claim to pseudonymity, or discussion with some Irish politician or whatnot. After being found out, they will then eventually apologize, do better next time and pay the fine, which pales in comparison to the profit gained from that data. Just as they are now replying to an order from a data protection official with: ‘Lol nope‘
        wutXthree 5y ago
        Just don't use Facebook or Facebook Companies products? Like probably most people don't?
        krono 5y ago

humanlion87 5y ago

> Facebook’s WhatsApp unit called Caspar’s claims “wrong” and said the order won’t stop the roll-out of the new terms. I don't understand how Facebook says this order will not stop the roll-out. Are they implying that the authority has no power to implement/enforce the ban?

Jonanin 5y ago
They incorrectly assumed (like much of the media) that this update was about sharing data of personal messages with Facebook, when it is in fact not.
- zwaps 5y ago
  It is, but not yet in the EU. It literally says : we will share everything with Facebook as soon as the EU allows. Right now we do not. But we might. I mean it’s written there.
  - tpush 5y ago
    Where does it literally say that?
    - zwaps 5y ago
      I quote from their website ——— Today, WhatsApp does not share your personal information with Facebook to improve your Facebook product experiences or provide you more relevant Facebook ad experiences on Facebook. This is a result of discussions with the Irish Data Protection Commission and other Data Protection Authorities in Europe. We're always working on new ways to improve how you experience WhatsApp and the other Facebook Company Products you use. Should we choose to share such data with the Facebook Companies for this purpose in the future, we will only do so when we reach an understanding with the Irish Data Protection Commission on a future mechanism to enable such use. We'll keep you updated on new experiences we offer and our information practices. —————— This is legalese for pretty much what I posted. In particular, the keep you update here does not necessarily mean you get to agree to a new privacy policy, as the current policy does not include a commitment not to share data (for ads etc) with facebook in the first place. This statement is deviously placed outside the privacy policy! Also further up they say that they associate the whatsapp profile with any facebook profile in the household/net/vicinity. To be clear, they do this now. Not in the future.
      - zwaps 5y ago
        Oh just on case you are unsure what will happen with all this, it’s the following: In the near future, they will start sharing all that juicy data with facebook based on some made up precedent, new technical justification, some claim to pseudonymity, or discussion with some Irish politician or whatnot. After being found out, they will then eventually apologize, do better next time and pay the fine, which pales in comparison to the profit gained from that data. Just as they are now replying to an order from a data protection official with: ‘Lol nope‘
        wutXthree 5y ago
        Just don't use Facebook or Facebook Companies products? Like probably most people don't?
        krono 5y ago