3 ms·
I'm an ideas person, but I can back it up with the necessary toil to bring an idea to life. But frequently, ideas require multiple people's worth of expertise
by klyrs 6y ago
I'm an ideas person, but I can back it up with the necessary toil to bring an idea to life. But frequently, ideas require multiple people's worth of expertise to succeed.
A healthy attitude, in my experience, is for others to workshop an idea that has a potential for a good payoff; both finding flaws and finding workarounds. This occurs with an open, collaborative culture.
An unhealthy attitude is expecting somebody with a good idea to put in 100% of the effort themselves, because that requires them to relearn/reinvent everybody else's specializations. This happens more with a rigid or competitive culture.
A survival strategy in the latter environment is to keep one's ideas secret, and (theoretically) solve future problems before anybody else knows that they'll crop up. In this way, an ideas person becomes the clinch-problem-solving-person because when the house is burning down, people are more willing to collaborate.
- ChrisMarshallNY 6y agoI've always found that an iterative collaboration between "idea" people and "execution" people has yielded the best results. If your idea is that good, and you can't trust your "executor," then it's an idea that will either die in the crib, or will come out as a mutated, unhealthy monster. Collaboration, between dedicated, creative ("execution people" can be very creative, you know) team members, working on an equal footing, with mutual respect and authority, works well (in my experience). The company I worked at for years was not an especially creative one, but it had some heavy-duty science going on. Some of the folks they had in their R&D department were some of the best in the world. But they also had a codified system, that worked fairly well, to realize their inventions in a way that could be commoditized, and that was because some of their "execution" people were also among the best in the world.
- klyrs 6y ago> "execution people" can be very creative, you know Echoing me here :) -- main problem with the article is that it represents, no, encourages, black-and-white thinking at a management level. Most of us are quite flexible, and tick both boxes, but we'll identify stronger with the label that feels more rewarding.
- anonymouse008 6y ago> An unhealthy attitude is expecting somebody with a good idea to put in 100% of the effort themselves, because that requires them to relearn/reinvent everybody else's specializations. This happens more with a rigid or competitive culture. Yeah currently suffering from this... losing my mind coding the fifth 'refactor' (or better, learning I did everything wrong the last four times) so I can get to a product to generate enough revenue to appreciate a teammate's time by putting bread on their table. Self-inflicted. I'm lucky I don't need many calories to maintain a healthy body weight, but I may have traded all this for some crispy dendrites.