3 ms·
> With Tesla this car had supercharger access turned off and he could not get replacement parts to fix the car. This is a little disingenuous. It was a wreck,
by ajross 6y ago
> With Tesla this car had supercharger access turned off and he could not get replacement parts to fix the car.
This is a little disingenuous. It was a wreck, literally. It was a flooded car that the insurance had written off and sold as scrap. You'd never get manufacturer support for a BMW in the same circumstance either. Scrap is scrap.
That you can buy a car body and do a cool hack isn't a moral lesson about the business model attached to the car the part was taken from.
- jeffbee 6y agoA BMW dealer built a 1970s R90S motorcycle from parts they ordered from the BMW catalog in 2013. I personally rebuilt a wrecked 1989 Honda motorcycle with all factory parts in 2010. Traditional automakers provide excellent support for any years even for niche vehicles that hardly anyone bought.
- ajross 6y agoAnd you genuinely think you could do the same with a 2022 BMW i4 or Honda Clarity? More to the point: could you have build those same projects in the 70's/90's when those were new vehicles? I rather doubt it, too. Parts markets are real, but they take time to mature. I mean... where do you think the parts would even come from? Tesla's factories are at capacity building new vehicles (in the case of the model S and X, they're actually almost a year behind orders!). Who's going to make the stuff you'd expect to buy anyway?
- jeffbee 6y agoYes? I just punched up the front steering assembly for a 2020 Honda Clarity PHEV. All I need to do is click this button to have it shipped to me. Reasonable automakers make more parts than they need and ship them to warehouses worldwide to support their customer fleets. Here’s the whole battery pack assembly for my Honda. https://www.hondapartsonline.net/oem-parts/honda-pack-assembly-battery-1d1005wja10?c=Zz1lbGVjdHJpY2FsLWV4aGF1c3QtaGVhdGVyLWZ1ZWwmcz1iYXR0ZXJ5LXBhY2smbD0xJm49QXNzZW1ibGllcyBQYWdlJmE9aG9uZGEmbz1jbGFyaXR5Jnk9MjAyMCZ0PXBsdWctaW4taHlicmlkJmU9MS01bC1sNC1lbGVjdHJpYy1nYXM%3D https://www.hondapartsonline.net/oem-parts/honda-pack-assemb...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 6y agond you genuinely think you could do the same with a 2022 BMW i4 I do not expect to be able to buy replacement parts for a car that isn't yet on sale... I do expect that I will be able to buy replacement parts for it once the car is on sale, as is the case with all of BMW's other vehicles.
- toast0 6y ago> You'd never get manufacturer support for a BMW in the same circumstance either. You don't need manufacturer support to repair most cars. Several car makers have left the industry, and their cars are still drivable and repairable. You can generally buy and repair cars with flood or wrecked title and repair them if you've got the time and patience; manufacturers will probably think you're crazy, but you can get service parts.
- ajross 6y agoThat's just not true of modern vehicles and you know it. You can't get a dash display replacement for a 2021 Audi or whatever from anyone but Audi, etc... You can't get an engine control computer for your new Toyota from anyone but Toyota. It's absolutely true that engine parts can be made in a machine shop by a suitably talented artisan, so there remains a third party parts market for those things where there isn't for e.g. 20nm digital logic fabrication, NMC battery cells, etc... But that's because one of those things is century old technology and the other isn't. It's not a business model thing, at all.
- sesellis 6y agoBut Audi will sell you the parts in your example. The display went out in my wife's 2018 Toyota, I went online and bought the part through a dealer and installed it myself. That's not very possible to do with Tesla, and I think that's the point here.
- jsight 6y agohttps://epc.tesla.com/en/catalogs/2/categories/37/subcategories/24948/systemGroups/47363 https://epc.tesla.com/en/catalogs/2/categories/37/subcategor... The Tesla screen is available from Tesla's parts departments. You don't even need to own a car to buy it.
- Symbiote 6y agoThe point was being able to buy things without a warranty or even owning the appropriate car. Whether third parties sell them is less important. Audi instrument clusters, for 2021 models [1] — Audi appear to be willing to sell these to me, even though I don't own a car. [2] seems to be a third party retailer. [1] https://parts.audiusa.com/productSearch.aspx?&ukey_make=5792&ukey_model=0&modelYear=2021&ukey_category=0&ukey_driveline=0&ukey_trimlevel=0&ukey_modelRange=0&isOnSale=0&searchTerm=instrument%20cluster https://parts.audiusa.com/productSearch.aspx?&ukey_make=5792... [2] https://www.audionlineparts.com/ https://www.audionlineparts.com/
- mfer 6y agoPeople by scrapped ICE cars all the time. It may not be one of the mainstream options but it's not rare. It's common. It's possible to fix it up to get a rebuilt title after it had a salvage title from being an insurance write-off. The fact that filling up a car at a charging/fueling station requires manufacturer support highlights how coupled everything is together.
- _ph_ 6y agoI am sure, it is possible to charge the salvaged Tesla at most power outlets. Just not high-power chargers, which makes a lot of sense.
- syshum 6y agoPretty Sure BMW will sell you the parts, any parts, if you have the $$$, they will not even ask you the VIN Number, go down to the local deal, tell them you need X parts, and have Y Cash in hand they say "here you go" Tesla attempting to turn cars in iPhone Walled Garden where you need approval to fix them and only allow to use Manufacture Approved Repair Centers likely will be the down fall of this, as people will not stand for this long term like they have with Cell phones, ironically this type of Automotive lock down (which Tesla is far from the only offender) will likely be the cause of Right to Repair laws being passed in most states very soon that will extend to all manner of electronics including Cell Phones
- mgarfias 6y agoMy plan with the mode y my wife just bought herself is to sell in 3-4 years. My 1T diesel pickup won’t be retired like this. I don’t like this approach, but it is what it is.
- bri3d 6y ago> You'd never get manufacturer support for a BMW in the same circumstance either. There's no network of BMW gas stations that you need to pay a license fee to use, though. Otherwise I generally agree.
- _ph_ 6y agoYou don't need to charge at superchargers. Any other charger would do. But considering the voltage and currents at the superchargers, I can only support to limit the usage to undamaged vehicles.