3 ms·
I'd be tempted to add TC, Mashable and the like to that as well. Though the stories are good, how many HN readers also visit those sites anyway. Maybe a grey-l
by pedalpete 18y ago
I'd be tempted to add TC, Mashable and the like to that as well. Though the stories are good, how many HN readers also visit those sites anyway.
Maybe a grey-list for anything linking to those sites, and then one of the top 100 users needs to vote it up in order for the article to be white-listed? Something like that? Unfortunately, that means that the most dedicated users are burdened in cleaning things up for the rest of the community, but by definition, they are already dedicated and would probably/hopefully like the site cleaned up for everybody.
I'm curious where the 'Rate my start-ups' fit into this? Do people like them? Or do you find this to not be the best venue to view them.
I posted my start-up here and the feedback I got was amazing, but that doesn't mean the community wants that stuff here.
- xenoterracide 18y agoI still like the idea of categorizing things like startup feedback. and ask hn/yc/pg.
- maxwell 18y agoAn "ask" or "questions" link in the nav bar could work, which would just show posts with /^Ask .+:/.
- stcredzero 18y agoThat would make those "opt-in," which would be a good thing to me.
- saundby 18y agoI don't mind the "rate my start-up" questions that have a clear question about something specific that can be evaluated and responded to directly. Things like "here's what we're trying to do here and how, how effective do you think we're being at this?" as opposed to an open-ended "rate my start-up" with a url where we're supposed to do a top to bottom review to solve their business or presentation problems for them.
- amackera 18y agoI really like the "Rate my start-ups" posts, assuming the HN doesn't get swamped with them. It's fun to hear the feedback of different people with different attitudes. We're all (or mostly) "start-up minded" here at HN so that's a plus too. I've never submitted one of these, for reference, I just like to read them.