3 ms·
Consciousness has a specific meaning, even though we can't formally define it so far. That includes reactiveness, feelings, curiosity and other traits, which el
by tsimionescu 6y ago
Consciousness has a specific meaning, even though we can't formally define it so far. That includes reactiveness, feelings, curiosity and other traits, which elementary particles obviously do not possess. So, it is obvious that elementary particles are not conscious.
Now, you could say that consciousness is a quantity that humans possess a lot of, while photons possess a tiny little amount of, like the Integrated Information Theory people claim. But there is no proof (or even indication, in my opinion) that the IIT 'consciousness' actually captures what we mean by human consciousness.
> It follows that, if true randomness is exhibited by the universe, one that is not generated by rules, then it must be the leftover ingredient. Consciousness is the only leftover ingredient. Everything else we know about physics is deterministic and rule-based.
Randomness is not necessarily a part of QM. For example, in MWI, there is no randomness in the universe - it is perfectly deterministic, as every state of the wave function is realized. In pilot-wave theory, the only randomness is classical - errors in knowing the initial state with absolute precision.
Even if CI or other fundamental randomness interpretations of QM are correct, there is no obvious connection between consciousness and randomness. There are other unknowns in the universe - you could just as easily say that dark matter is consciousness or dark matter is the source of randomness, or dark energy etc.
And only since you briefly mentioned it, free will (as in conscious choice affecting the next state of the universe) is incompatible with QM, as QM is a linear theory, where the next state is uniquely determined by the previous state, especially in MWI.
- goldenkey 6y agoEssential consciousness is the self appearance of free will. MWI still has randomness - how do you think you reside in one universe versus a different one? You keep sidestepping with erroneous statements. Rules are not a source of real randomness and there is a consensus among physicists that quantum randomness is actually true randomness. Even if you put the source of randomness into some other thing like dark matter, you cannot explain its construct..because all you have is rules. You must forfeit and concede to nature a black box RNG library. This is clearly ludicrous. The more obvious and consistent view is that conscious beings (that feel they have willful decisions) are the manifestation of nature's RNG for quantum mechanics IIT is an entirely different beast related to self attention, a different kind of definition for consciousness, that has little to do with will. Unrelated... QM is unitary, but it is one to many. It's a giant branching rooted tree. This is irrelevant, it is not deterministic like general relativity. Please step back in the element. These refutations are becoming exhausting.
- tsimionescu 6y agoNo, MWI has no randomness. All versions of you exist and are as real. The moment after the Big Bang, the fact that we would be having this conversation in the year 2021 on Earth was certain. This is an absolute requirement from the linearity of the Schrodinger's equation, which means that every state is uniquely determined by the states that came before. If you could measure the state of the universe with enough precision, you could tell today what I will feel tomorrow. And sure, each copy of you may experience a different comment, but they are indistinguishable, and all possible comments will be experienced. In CI there is indeed true randomness, since only one 'branch' of the wavefunction is actually happening.
- goldenkey 6y agoThe randomness in MWI is observer-centric. It's trivially obvious. You reside in one world of many. The theory doesn't explain why your consciousness follows a specific bifurcation. The supposed copies of you are irrelevant.
- tsimionescu 6y agoThe theory does not allow for 'your consciousness' to exist as a meaningful concept that experiences more than one moment. Say you are going to flip a quantum coin. Before you flip it, given MWI, you know that there will be two copies of you, each experiencing one of the outcomes. After you flip it, one copy sees tails, the other heads. Each copy is perfectly identical except for the new observation. Each may ask itself 'what were the chances that I am seeing heads/tails?', and with MWI in mind, they should answer 1: the chance that the copy-that-sees-heads sees heads is 1, and same for copy-who-sees-tails seeing tails, since there is no other way to identify them as separate entities. This also corresponds to the mathematics of QM: if you want to give proper predictions, you need to 'update' the wavefunciton to have value 1 for the observed outcome and value 0 for any other outcome. Doing that for 'your branch' is precisely how MWI works.
- goldenkey 6y ago