7 ms·
Scientists prefer studying pretty plants to dull ones
- focom 6y agoIf you have to live and think day and night about a plant, I can understand you pick the pretty one. But like with spider I am sure some people will get affection for the less loved one.
- munk-a 6y agoThe opener of the synopsis - that scientific interest is skewed toward charismatic organisms is one of the least interesting points I think you could raise - it is obviously true due to the fact that people are going to study things that interests them. If a plant is suspected as being a big leap toward the cure of cancer we'll see a lot of scientists suddenly invest a lot of effort into studying it - similarly we see a lot of scientific focus around relatively novel plants because they have interesting attributes. The interesting thing for me in this study is that we've got a strong tie to surface level appearance - color and morphology in particular. So, we may have to supply some incentives to love those drab beige plants that aren't getting enough attention.
- 7952 6y agoThere must be an evolutionary basis for some of this. Reacting to the appearance of plants could be really useful to a foraging human. But as modern humans we have repurposed that skill towards something more abstract. Pretty daffodils instead of starchy foods. But we probably all have some capacity to use that ability.
- whyenot 6y ago> The interesting thing for me in this study is that we've got a strong tie to surface level appearance I'm not surprised. Studying charismatic species will likely help with getting you funding, is more likely to get you news coverage, attract graduate students, etc. Keep in mind that field botany is not very well supported by the NSF. Those who work in this area often have to find other sources for funding. Studying a plant that looks good to the members of the California Native Plant Society, for example is not necessarily a bad strategy. I have no hard numbers, but you can see a similar pattern in other areas of field biology. For example, it sure looks like there are a lot more people studying birds and cute furry mammals than reptiles, fish, or insects.
- montalbano 6y agoAs Poincaré said a while ago: The scientist does not study nature because it is useful; he studies it because he delights in it, and he delights in it because it is beautiful. If nature were not beautiful, it would not be worth knowing, and if nature were not worth knowing, life would not be worth living. On a separate note, Arabidopsis isn't that pretty yet it has been The Model System in plant science for years..
- flobosg 6y agoModel organisms such as Arabidopsis thaliana are usually chosen based on criteria other than prettiness.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- devin 6y agoNot in the field you're referring to, but C. Elegans also comes to mind.
- nonameiguess 6y agoYou know, if I could have my time again, I think I would be a microbial ecologist. I would spend my time studying micro-organisms in their natural environment. I'd cut my way through forests of bacteria on a grain of sand. I would imagine myself in a submarine in a drop of water that seemed as large as a lake, and for one more turn around, I would be an explorer naturalist in a new world. E.O. Wilson
- op03 6y agoIts probably cause its easy to grow and you can get 8 generations a year to study in the lab.
- 0xbadcafebee 6y agoIn other news, humans make pretty animals their pets, eat the ugly ones.
- gnulinux 6y agoNot only that but I feed other animals to my pretty cat. He's a beautiful animal though...
- globular-toast 6y agoThey eat pretty ones too, like horses. Just not in America...
- giantg2 6y agoDon't tell my wife. She'll cry.
- dnautics 6y agoI love both cats and dogs, but there are definitely some ugly species of both, that aren't even adorably ugly.
- ExtraE 6y agoI wonder which way ‘round this happened.
- optimalsolver 6y agoThe Chad orchid vs the virgin philodendron.
- pvaldes 6y agoYeah, I almost feel pity for that wheat, corn or microalgae that nobody studies... (And the theory that claims that any article starting with "scientists do this or that" is bullshit, wins again).
- globular-toast 6y agoI can't quite tell if this is sarcasm or not. If it's not sarcasm, wheat and corn have been studied loads. I worked at an institute that specialised in cereals. If it is sarcasm, I actually find wheat and corn quite pretty. No comment on mircoalgae, though.
- dnautics 6y agoWe study yeast like crazy. Hint: it's not because of bread. And the knock-on effects of studying yeast have been good for other fields (students t-test e.g.)
- wnissen 6y agoHow do you think scientists get interested in plants in the first place? I'm a recreational scuba diver, which means that my hobby is to to go underwater and try to see stuff that is neat. Of course I want to see the pretty colorful fishes and sea slugs! No diver spends thousands traveling to far flung destinations to peer at the dull and ugly. Right now I have no scientific purpose, but I bet there is an almost perfect correlation with people who like to scuba dive and go on to be marine researchers.
- bigyikes 6y agoIn an alternate reality I’m a scuba diving marine biologist. I hated biology in school, but I’ve always had a soft spot for fish. Now I think biology is cool and so I have some ragrets. Scuba diving is something I’ve always wanted to do, but never put any effort into getting started. Thanks for nudging me in that direction.
- Hammershaft 6y agoI think this points towards the inability of traditional schooling to engage kids in educational topics. I experienced something similiar where I bounced off math in school, partially because it was taught to me as rote memorization. Only years later did I realize how much I enjoy learning maths.
- the_only_law 6y agoI had a love for biology even before programming, though it was kinda difficult to do anything with it outside or reading books I could on partially understand. Of course, even today I’m not sure I could stomach the salary they pay biologists and I’m even open to a pay cut to some degree.
- ip26 6y agoLife sciences as a field is known for grueling repetitive manual labor and rock bottom wages (because so many people are passionate about life sciences). Traditional schooling has its flaws, but in the case of life science I would argue it goes the other way- students are dazzled by the cool parts and unaware of the slog after school.
- danschumann 6y agoAm I the only one with a subscription to plain plants monthly, where the centerfold is typically a form of highland wheat?
- doggodaddo78 6y agoSssh. There's a support group down the hall. Don't tell anyone else because we're very embarrassed about it.
- golemotron 6y agoIt's interesting that they don't consider cultivating more charismatic plants serve the various ecosystem niches. It would allow scientists to align with their inclinations over time.
- doggodaddo78 6y agoPlant rolls +8 CHA, +3 AGI, +10 INT.
- not2b 6y agoI suspect that it's easier to get funding to research pretty plants or to try to preserve them, and less charismatic plants and animals are much more likely to attract scorn from small-government types trying to "ferret out government waste". And if the money's going to be raised from private donors the effect is going to be even worse: save the redwoods or pandas, lots of money. Save the snail darter (crickets).
- qchris 6y agoI have a friend/coworker who refers to these as "boutique" ecosystems/organisms. They're the ones that are really easy to love/study/want to preserve, like coral reefs and clownfish, or kelp forests and sea otters.
- doggodaddo78 6y agoDamn plant halo effect biases. Ugly plants have great personalities if they'd try chatting with them.
- ggm 6y agoTobacco Mosaic virus was heavily studied by plant biologists, and its hardly pretty. Canola came about because scientists wanted to work on yield of a boring plant: Rapeseed fields are monochromatic yellow. I worked in a marine biology lab, the PhDs there were obsessed with Kelp, one of the most un-lovely plants I can imagine but a kelp forest is a beautiful thing, if you understand it. Mangrove swamps are as ugly as all hell. They teem with life but there's no beauty innately in the mangrove per se. I just don't agree with this conclusion, evidence not withstanding. I think there has to be some sample bias creeping in. Really? I think scientists want to work on interesting problems. If they attract funds, so much the better. But, Scientists defy typing. Some of them are collectors, some of them are dissectors, some of them are "how-does-it-workers", some of them are "how-can-I-kill-it" specialists. Pretty is in the eye of the beholder.
- rapjr9 6y agoThis is a specific version of a more general problem, namely that scientists only study what interests them, therefore there are gaps in what gets studied. There are fads in scientific research, just like everything else people do. Not sure what the solution is (more diversely targeted grant funds for basic research?) but we almost did not have an mRNA vaccine because mRNA research was not popular at one time. I'm not sure there are even surveys to identify these gaps. You occasionally see papers or articles about "open questions in discipline X" but those are still only aimed at popular research interests. Truly identifying gaps in research direction is partly impossible for areas no one knows anything about, but it seems like a group of people with deep knowledge could at least create a partial map of the territory. The microbiome probably remained unstudied for so long because it was a "yucky" area of research that no one wanted to study. Research into cures for liver diseases were not popular because "they would just encourage people to drink". I'm sure there are many other examples.
- op03 6y agoAs a gardener, who is constantly taking photos of my plants and tagging them, I noticed the same pattern while generating stats on all the tags collected over time. The frequency of photos would increase when there was flowering, fruiting, growth spurts, interesting leaf growth etc but the plant would get totally ignored for long periods if its neighbour was doing something more interesting or if it was struck by diseases/bugs, wilting, dying etc. I also realized my least photographed subjects are weeds. Even though a lot of time is spent looking for them and managing them and just being gobsmaked at how unbelievably good they are at surviving whatever the universe throws at them. I have a dumb script that generates a periodic report on all the tags to tell me which plant/tag hasnt been clicked for a while. It hasnt really made me a more disciplined but I feel its constantly reminding me of what I getting bored off and where my interests lie.
- stinos 6y agoI also realized my least photographed subjects are weeds That probably depends on your definition of weeds then, yours seems quite strict? Almost meaing 'pest' perhaps? Here in Western Europe, especially in previous generations, the term tends to get used for pretty much everything which is bascially just a native wild plant. It's ok if it's short grass or when you can buy it in a store, but otherwise the label is 'weed'. And I'm really not exaggerating here. As such if you want to take photgraphs of plants outdoors those 'weeds' are the targets. Even the most common ones tend to be rather beautiful.
- op03 6y agoThats interesting :) I like the perspective. Yup I was taught to think of them as pests, especially when then get close too or tangled up with some of the more "delicate" plants. Another issue is whenever curiosity spikes, its not that easy to identify them or get more info about them by simple googling or looking at books (my botanical technical vocabulary isnt that great) so they remain these mysterious unidentified unknowns. But yeah totally agree they are beautiful in their own way and are constantly surprising me.
- K33P4D 6y agoAh yes aesthetic usability effect
- stared 6y agoCompare with another serious topic: cancer deaths vs funding: - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1124435/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC1124435/ - https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3411479/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3411479/ Breast cancer (and leukemia, as it affects kids) are proportionally the most funded ones. Rectal cancer (with a similar DALY loss as breast cancer) does not receive nearly as much funding. Lung cancer (which is common and deadly) gets little funding, as we associate it with people taking their own risk with smoking, even though often it is not the case (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27023395 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27023395, https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/0141076819843654 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/full/10.1177/01410768198436...).
- Engineering-MD 6y agoSlight correction. Most lung cancer is due to smoking, although around 5% are not as your links demonstrate. Share of funding in research is hard and does often play on emotions. There is an interesting concept of funding for “orphan drugs/diseases” from governments for diseases so rare they would never get funded at all from private companies. It’s an interesting ethical question whether these should get funded. https://jme.bmj.com/content/medethics/31/3/164.full.pdf https://jme.bmj.com/content/medethics/31/3/164.full.pdf
- thatcat 6y agoHow do you know the origin of the particle that causes the cancer? Seems like lung cancer is just attributed to smoking when a lung cancer patient has smoked.
- Engineering-MD 6y agoWell, if you want to go down the rabbit hole of causation, there is very little you can say definitely, as proving causation is practically impossible. So you can never say what caused any disease. Having said that, most diseases are multifactorial in origin, with cells mostly having multiple insults to lead to cancer- both on an individual cell and cell population basis. For types of cancer associated with smoking (like non adenocarcinomas of the lung), its likely that smoking contributed to at least one of the insults causing a cell to undergo metaplasia/dysplasia or become cancerous, or statistically would be likely to lead to that cancer on a cell population basis.
- tgv 6y agoPerhaps it's not because they're attractive to the researcher, but rather to the reviewer?
- kogens 6y agoScientists also tend to study what they can get funding for, which is often easier for more beautiful or easily explainable subjects.