4 ms·
I suspect Matlab will have a long tail in engineering education, for a number of reasons: 1) It's effectively free for educational use thanks to generous site l
by analog31 6y ago
I suspect Matlab will have a long tail in engineering education, for a number of reasons: 1) It's effectively free for educational use thanks to generous site licenses. 2) A lot of curricula have been developed around it. 3) Indisputably, it works.
But outside of academia, let's face it, the most widespread "engineering IDE" is Excel. Relatively few engineers continue to use math and equations after they graduate. A lot of their calculations can be done in Excel, or within their CAD software. The biggest threat to Matlab is the automation of engineering calculations.
As a result, it's more mixed, with the people who are actually doing quantitative work coming from a variety of fields including math and physics, but also from areas that have no prior loyalty to Matlab such as biology and statistics.
For instance in my department, any deeply quantitative work is done by a very small handful of "math people" who may or may not have "engineer" job titles, but whose degrees are in math or the physical sciences.
- chris_wot 6y agoDear God I hope engineers doing anything safety related aren’t using Excel!
- krapht 6y agoWhy?
- chris_wot 6y agoBecause it’s not accurate. So far as I’m aware, even today it’s statistical functions still have flaws. Don’t use Excel.
- rurban 6y agoI once sold a program for large network optimization problem in Excel. The calculations of the sewer planning for an entire district, a few million homes in northern Italy. Excel was the best for the job, integrated into a CAD package. Safety? Wrong planning could lead to some problems as seenm in poorly planned cities (e.g. Houston), but I guess they are largely ignorable. "Common Mistakes in Planning of Sewer Networks and STPs" https://www.springerprofessional.de/common-mistakes-in-planning-of-sewer-networks-and-stps/15259600 https://www.springerprofessional.de/common-mistakes-in-plann... My district was properly planned, Excel was the best. Would not recommend doing something similar by hand.
- analog31 6y agoThere's a lot of engineering that just isn't at that level of critical. If it is, then they do it in their CAD software. If it's safety related, there might be just one person in the department who handles that kind of stuff. Now, I have a relative who is a retired nuclear power plant operator. They did things a bit more formally there. ;-)