5 ms·
No, some idiots who are going to find themselves made examples of tried to do a ransomeware attack on another group of idiots who didn’t take computer security
by colechristensen 6y ago
No, some idiots who are going to find themselves made examples of tried to do a ransomeware attack on another group of idiots who didn’t take computer security seriously enough who also happened to control a major piece of us infrastructure that they (claim) they shut down out of caution.
Some people are going to prison, some other people are going to start taking infrastructure security more seriously, and fuel traders are going to make a lot of money.
This is exactly how our brittle infrastructure gets fixed in the best imaginable way. Millions of people minority inconvenienced so that politicians will start regulating a poorly self regulating piece of essential infrastructure.
- bsder 6y ago> This is exactly how our brittle infrastructure gets fixed in the best imaginable way. Millions of people minority inconvenienced so that politicians will start regulating a poorly self regulating piece of essential infrastructure. I'll believe it when the next cold snap in Texas doesn't wipe out the grid. This happened in 2011. The feds even made a report. Nobody did shit. This happened in 2021. Nobody has done shit. This will happen again. Nobody will do shit. If doing shit costs money, nobody will do it. If you want it done, it needs to be law and the penalty needs to be jail, not fines.
- colechristensen 6y agoThe consequence needs to be liability and the penalty insurance coverage. Nothing like an insurance company tripling your rates after a bad audit to motivate executives. Threat of jail invites regulatory capture and obfuscations to evade prosecutors (who are most often defeated by making crimes as convoluted as possible so they don’t think they can convince a jury)
- dredmorbius 6y agoYou and bsder are both right.
- bsder 6y ago> The consequence needs to be liability and the penalty insurance coverage. No, because bankruptcy discharges the liability. And that's exactly what's happening in Texas right now is a bunch of companies are going bankrupt after having skimmed off the top. If it's fundamental infrastructure, there should be minimum rules and if you fail those rules you go to jail. People died because a bunch of executives decided that it was too expensive to winterize properly.
- novok 6y agoJail leads to the scummiest who don't care much about jail doing it, or it being impossible to find the service anymore because nobody wants to do it, and for essential infrastructure, you don't want a large amount of avoidance in providing infra.
- bsder 6y ago> or it being impossible to find the service anymore because nobody wants to do it, and for essential infrastructure, you don't want a large amount of avoidance in providing infra. Gee, wouldn't it be nice if there was only some mechanism to collectively fund essential infrastructure that the free market finds too unprofitable ... Yeah, I'm kind of cranky about people who put "profit" and "essential infrastructure" in the same sentence. There is scant evidence that contracting "essential infrastructure" out of government has actually improved things and lots of evidence that it has not (both the Texas (supposedly light regulations) cold snap fiasco and the ongoing PG&E fiasco in California (supposedly heavy regulations)).
- novok 6y agoLegislation that involves jail usually doesn't care if it's a government employee or a corporation doing it, and those govt employees will display similar avoidance behaviors.
- Syonyk 6y ago> Some people are going to prison, some other people are going to start taking infrastructure security more seriously... Can you point to evidence that this has happened as you state it will? There's decades of stuff being impacted by various cybersecurity vulnerabilities, and I'm not aware of anyone going to jail over it (defenders claim Act of God, attackers are in some country without extradition treaties and can't be identified anyway, or just pay off the local government to protect them). I'm also not aware of much of anything in the way of actually fixing the problems. Ask anyone who has done any red teaming at any level how often the bugs get fixed, and how often the report is filed away with a nice "Thank you for meeting our checkbox of having been red teamed, here's your check." And the same configurations are in play 5 years later. Keep your old notes, they may be useful! > This is exactly how our brittle infrastructure gets fixed in the best imaginable way. I'll bet it doesn't.
- colechristensen 6y agoi don’t think this one incident is going to fix everything, but i do think that a clear cut security incident affecting major infrastructure for millions will get at least a little political attention we don’t seem likely to get much done by security people making warnings, failure is the best teacher and i think the right people will learn at least a little here
- petre 6y agoSome Russian security "researchers" are going to be arrested the moment they set foot on US or Canadian soil for attending some conference or are going to be detained in transit. That's how it happens. Like it happened to the Huawei CFO. Some others are going to find their accounts frozen.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]