3 ms·
This point feels a little strained. There is a question: "Was autopilot in use?", and an experiment was performed to answer that question, which produced an in
by ajross 6y ago
This point feels a little strained. There is a question: "Was autopilot in use?", and an experiment was performed to answer that question, which produced an informative result, which was reported. You seem to be attacking the linguistic structure of the statement by interpreting "coudn't" to mean some kind of existentially inviolate truth and not just... the result of the experiment.
I mean, come on. This is what people were saying within hours after the crash: autopilot as shipped simply doesn't have behavior consistent with this accident. It won't command the accelerations that would have been required on that tiny street and (as measured by the NTSB) won't even engage in that particular environment.
- breakyerself 6y agoMy car has never allowed AP to be engaged on roads without lines painted on it. There was no update that took that functionality away.
- JPKab 6y agoYes this is true. Basically every Tesla owner that saw the story knew right away that it was being sensationalized. I was very surprised to see the LA times jump on it when they certainly have numerous employees that drive these vehicles.
- 2rsf 6y agoIt is sensationalized, but it could have a bug and not a designed behavior. This could have been a software bug or a rare combination with hardware or environment conditions.
- brianwawok 6y agoGreat, so the bug would need to be proven. A newspaper can't decide what happened the day of the crash with no evidence.
- 2rsf 6y ago> My car has never allowed That is an anecdotal result > There was no update that took that functionality away Maybe not explicitly, but we all know how software works
- orra 6y ago> There is a question: "Was autopilot in use?", and an experiment was performed to answer that question Why an experiment? Isn't there a Black Box, like on aeroplanes, with logs to definitively answer the question?
- jussij 6y agoFrom the article: The report said the car's lithium-ion battery case was damaged, and in the ensuing fire the infotainment system's onboard storage device was destroyed.
- richardkmichael 6y agoThe very next sentence of the article: However, the "restraint control module," which stores data such as whether seatbelts were in use, how fast the vehicle was going, acceleration information, and airbag deployment, although damaged by fire was recovered and turned over to the NTSB's laboratory to evaluate.
- c-cube 6y agoThe point is that Tesla can do over the air updates, which means (in theory!) that the experiment could be gamed because it would use a different version of the software.