3 ms·
FWIW I don't think the Tweet referenced is dumb. It might not have taken much effort to create, but it is funny, easily digestible and presents a situation that
by paxys 6y ago
FWIW I don't think the Tweet referenced is dumb. It might not have taken much effort to create, but it is funny, easily digestible and presents a situation that a ton of professionals can relate to.
Humor is situational and often counterintuitive. There is no formula for a good joke, and staying up till 3am trying to draft a successful Tweet is the exact wrong way to do it. While I am glad the author recognized the problem, writing a semi-pretentious blog post about it and posting it on HN for further validation rather than just switching off his computer tells me that he isn't out of the woods just yet.
- GuB-42 6y agoThe "dumb" part is that neither the graph nor the quote are his. He just slapped the two together and it made a hit. He brought little value to the joke. But that's how memes work, they mutate, evolve, and what he did was he introduced a slight mutation in the original joke that helped its spread. Maybe his Twitter account also has the right connections.
- garbagetime 6y agoI'm not seeing how that's dumb.
- alanbernstein 6y agoHe didn't actually call it "dumb", rather "my dumbest". Maybe compare to his other tweets for context.
- my_usernam3 6y agoI think "dumb" in text form might be the wrong word. In conversation this would sound normal to me. Given the blog post of what he is talking about, "dumbest" sounds better than "my super simple joke I thought of and made in a few minutes". Ironically, I think he partly considers it "dumbest" because he didn't overthink it... like I'm doing to the author's use of "dumbest" hehe.
- beowulfey 6y agoThe dumb part is the amount of effort it took to make, i.e. none
- ziml77 6y agoWhen your audience is quickly scrolling through posts on the internet, there is absolutely a formula. From all the time I spent on Reddit in my early 20s, I know very well that the most upvoted posts are almost always the ones the require the least effort to consume. That means that just a few words and an image are going to do the best. Leaning on things that are already familiar helps too since there will already be an association with a meaning of the image or the text structure.