4 ms·
"She has no grasp on the effect..." "...the guy who put it forth has no clue about how the internet works..." "...has literally no clue how this works and doe
by scarmig 15y ago
"She has no grasp on the effect..."
"...the guy who put it forth has no clue about how the internet works..."
"...has literally no clue how this works and doesn't care a whit about the effect it will have..."
Really? Is e-commerce so weak that it can't compete on a level playing field with physical retail? Even if you think it is that weak, is it really so outlandish for people to think it can that it's worth a page of venom-filled invective? Yeah, Amazon's cutting off its nose to spite its face here, but doesn't that mean you should be mad at Amazon, not the state government?
- kposehn 15y agoIt isn't that e-commerce is weak at all. The playing field is skewed in e-commerce's favor because it is often offering a better experience and price. A lot of mom&pop retailers have figured this out and started selling online. They sell on Amazon and eBay and reach the entire world. Many successful major online retailers started this way. Also, it is hard to not be upset when you go to the effort I have; I went to Sacramento and met with the politicians. I tried to change the course of this legislation. I stood up for others to try and keep this from happening. I can see the damage this is doing and how it won't gain the state any revenue at all. I don't blame Amazon and the other retailers for what they have to do. The are faced with a decision where they can be on the hook for something that is specifically designed to muck with them. The legislation forces them to do this, not the other way around. There is a definite fiscal incentive for them to terminate affiliates; and also one for affiliate to leave the state. In the end, tax revenue is lost by the state and the bill just forces businesses out :-/
- scarmig 15y agoThis ignores the critique that the "better experience and price" online retail offers comes about because Amazon doesn't have to pay sales tax. This makes everything Amazon sells 10% cheaper in California, which means that even a totally equivalent experience offered by WalMart would be seriously disadvantaged. That said, this is a very sub-optimal solution--it's lose-lose-lose. It comes down to the fact, though, that one of Amazon's key competitive advantages is being able to avoid sales tax, and no solution which is (a) genuinely achievable and (b) levels the playing field will be supported by Amazon.
- kposehn 15y agoI agree, it is a sub-optimal solution. However, Amazon does support the streamlined sales tax which would achieve both points. There needs to be some federal solution to make reporting easier and the streamline seems to be the best way put forth so far.
- fryguy 15y agoThe problem isn't that it can't compete on a level price playing field, but a level tax-reporting playing field. When you live in Sacramento, and go to San Francisco and buy a sandwich, you pay the local sales tax. A store has a physical presence in one location. It collects sales taxes for once district: namely, the one it's in. Presumably at least one person works at the physical location, and can total the receipts at the end of the month, and send a cheque and associated paperwork to the state and/or county and/or city. The problem is that California wants amazon to collect sales taxes from customers who live in California, even though they have no physical presence. This bill is saying that they do have a physical presence (i.e. someone that can send in the cheque and associated paperwork) because someone puts up a banner ad on their website and happen to live in California. It would be like Sacramento wanting the shop in San Francisco to collect additional Sacramento city sales tax because I'm from there. Keep in mind that I'm not a CPA, and these analogies probably suck.
- scarmig 15y agoIn substance, that's a bad analogy. If you order something from WalMart.com, you have to pay sales tax for your jurisdiction, even though it's not a physical cashier in your jurisdiction ringing it up. It ends up giving Amazon an unfair advantage, just by virtue of the mere fact that it doesn't have physical retail locations in the states it sells stuff to.
- fryguy 15y agoThat's not really true though. When you buy things on walmart.com, you can pick them up at the store. The same thing with the sears catalogue. In theory, because they are already submitting sales tax to the state, it's no additional burden to submit more sales tax for things coming from online sales. The reason it hasn't been the case for other things, is that it's an excessive burden of the mail-order retailers to figure out the amounts, and submit different forms for every state, even though they are only located in one.
- pbreit 15y agoNeither of your comments make much sense. Amazon already collects tax in a lot of states so collecting in more would not be a major burden except financially. And what kind of advantage is slogging to the store to pick up a purchase?
- grok2 15y agoI think, the primary reason to be mad about this is that the law in no way helps any one. It even seems like it will end up being a law that has negative effects. California affiliates will be cut-off by Amazon. So the affiliates either move their business out of state or they stop their business entirely. In either case, the state loses out on taxes that it currently gets from these affiliates. People buying from Amazon will continue buying from Amazon. So the local and big-box retailers do not really benefit. It is only the small subset of people who don't know about certain Amazon products and who might have come to know about them because of the various sites or blogs based on using Amazon affiliate links will now not know about these and contribute to buying from Amazon. So it makes sense to be mad that our lawmakers are spending time and effort on a useless law during a time of budget crisis.