3 ms·
All fair points, but let's get out of the clouds of idealism and look at the actual effects of the law. This law will move start-ups out of California without
by nostromo 15y ago
All fair points, but let's get out of the clouds of idealism and look at the actual effects of the law.
This law will move start-ups out of California without raising a single penny in new revenue. It may actually decrease the tax base by moving income out of the state!
So, yes, if you want CA to 'make a stand' to prove a point, fine -- but it makes no pragmatic sense for anyone.
- gojomo 15y agoMany states are now acting on this same issue, so the number of places a start-up could flee to is rapidly dropping. New York, Texas, North Carolina, Colorado, and Illinois are definitely out. And Amazon already collects sales taxes for North Dakota, Kansas, Kentucky, and Washington. So if your start-up is so sensitive to affiliate revenues you'll avoid all those states, have fun wherever you wind up. I suppose Portland remains a nice spot – no Oregon sales tax at all.
- kposehn 15y agoColorado is in the process of repealing the law - a bit of good news there :)
- nostromo 15y agoI think you're confused -- Amazon has affiliates in both Washington and New York; affiliates in those states are fine. And so are affiliates in the states that already collect sales tax that you list -- which makes me think you don't understand the issue at hand. Add in the 5 states that don't charge sales tax, and there are plenty of great options to locate a business.
- gojomo 15y agoYou're right that I was confused about the effect of being in a state where Amazon already has to collect sales tax. (I was thinking of tax-minimizing consumers, rather than the affiliates). When Amazon has a presence that requires them to pay sales taxes in any case, they have no credible threat to end affiliate payments. So, it's safe to remain an affiliate in those places. A happy result for Amazon, affiliates, and the States, apparently. California and others want that same deal. In New York, Amazon threatened to pull out but is temporarily paying sales tax (some reports suggest into escrow) and maintaining the affiliate program pending a legal challenge. Amazon may yet wind up losing their challenge, in which case they would have to decide whether to treat NY like other states where they collect sales tax – which would render being an affiliate safe – or to follow through on their affiliate freeze-out. New York has essentially chosen the same course as California, so it will likely be resolved the same way in both states. Other states, likely including Texas and Massachusetts pending current legislative battles, are following this approach as well. My point is: this isn't just a California-shooting-itself-in-the-foot situation, and a company can't just jump to anywhere-but-California to get back into the affiliate program. Many states, including many other top tech and business centers, are treating Amazon the same as California.
- lloyddobbler 15y agoJust to clarify - Amazon has DROPPED its affiliates in most of those states. In CO in particular (a state I know more about than any of the others), they sent a letter to all affiliates immediately terminating their association with Amazon as soon as the law was announced. Much as they just did with California. Simple fact is, affiliates don't meet the definition of a "nexus" in a state, as determined by the Supreme Court in the early 90's. This is just a quick money grab by a lot of bankrupt states, who are counting on Amazon to just bend over and take it. Unfortunately for them, they're actually winding up costing jobs and income tax revenue for their state, instead of increasing sales tax revenue. New York and Washington AMZN affiliates are fine, because Amazon recognizes that it has what meets the legal definition of a "nexus" in those states, and therefore needs to collect sales tax revenue - affiliates or not.
- hardtke 15y agoA perverse incentive of the current situation is that Amazon is prevented from having distribution warehouses in California even though that is where much of their stuff is shipped. How many jobs are we losing now and how much extra CO2 is getting spewed into the air because of this nonsensical tax exemption?