4 ms·
You see this advice a lot, but it's never very specific. "Just negotiate better!" OK, great... how? Most of us have no leverage besides our willingness to walk
by ryandrake 6y ago
You see this advice a lot, but it's never very specific. "Just negotiate better!" OK, great... how? Most of us have no leverage besides our willingness to walk away, and when the market is saturated with talent, it's usually fine for a company to just let you walk away. I bet for someone who happens to be the world's foremost expert in some niche skill the company needs, negotiating a higher comp is straightforward. For the 95+% of the rest of us, it goes kind of like this:
Candidate: I'd like $150K. Comparable companies offer people with my experience $150K.
Company: We'll offer you $100K.
Candidate: I'll walk if you give me less than $140K.
Company: Ok... Bye?
Candidate: How about a little more equity?
Company: How about no?
Candidate: OK. $130K and maybe a bigger potential bonus?
Company: We're already interviewing the next person.
- jupp0r 6y agoThe advice is to walk after "Company: We'll offer you $100K." and go to "Comparable companies". If there aren't any then you lied with point 1.
- munk-a 6y agoJust a pro-tip - there probably are companies willing to give you that bump, you just need to look for them. I really wish it were easier to get appropriate compensation but without a union or legislation it's all on you.
- ryandrake 6y agoThat's not negotiation, though. That's just walking away when the number isn't high enough. Negotiation implies some kind of discussion: back-and-forth, give-and-take. I've rarely experienced any discussion actually working. It's usually the company, who has all the power, giving a "take it or leave it" offer, and that's it.
- ipaddr 6y agoDepends on the size. Larger places not so much but if you talk to the owner during your interview you can go back and forth.
- kgantchev 6y agoI recommend reading "Never Split The Difference," the book is great and it has served me well in negotiations. Where you're right: yes, you need to foster the conversation. It's a skill that one develops with practice. Where you're wrong: I negotiate for my consulting business and I can guarantee you that the companies don't have "the power." The power is held by whoever is better at negotiating. If you're good at negotiating, you will hold the power.
- jupp0r 6y agoIf you really think that 1. your work is worth 150k 2. other comparable companies would pay you as much then why would you negotiate further at that point? It’s obvious that your interview partner is looking for someone cheaper. If they do want to hire you, they will make you a fair offer. Negotiation skills are about negotiating 180k in that situation.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- mywittyname 6y agoPretty much. I had one (out of about ten) company ever offer more from negotiation, and that was only because I had a counter offer from another place. And it was 10%. Every other company has been, "this is our best offer." I'm pretty far from a FAANG uber-dev though.
- Mehdi2277 6y agoI've had 3 jobs since college. First one I unintentionally negotiated the internship although did not negotiate the later full time conversion. 2nd/3rd jobs both were negotiated. 2nd job was around 20% increase while 3rd job was 17ish percent. I only had offers from 3 places for the 2nd/3rd job. So 2/3 were successful negotiations. The 17ish percent was also an easy negotiation as I basically just said the current offer number wasn't enough to make me leave my current role and the recruiter immediately jumped to that so they had a 2nd offer ready as a backup. The last company I couldn't get them to budge at all although to there credit they were near the top end of the pay band data I found in levels for the role. The companies were 1 small startup (first one) and then 3 big N type companies. I think startups tend to be negotiation friendly and have poorly defined pay bands anyway. big N is sorta used to them for candidates negotiating with multiple offers (or vs there current role).
- fennecfoxen 6y ago1. The company you describe was never going to pay you much more than $100k. If you wanted more than that, you should have picked a different company. Setting your salary is more about efficiently finding that other company, and less about negotiation. 2. Your willingness to walk away is, indeed, your primary leverage. Ongoing employment is a great way to have lots of leverage there — you can start filtering out offers at the "recruiter is emailing me" stage — otherwise, develop leverage by collecting multiple offers at once (lining up a variety of interviews so that they come in around the same time).
- 6gvONxR4sf7o 6y agoNone of us have leverage besides our willingness to walk away. That's not the difference. I see some people act like negotiating is an antagonistic game of chicken or something. In reality, it's just an amicable case of you finding your best options, communicating them clearly to everyone involved, then taking the best option. Think of it as more like an auction than some slick game of poker. What's wrong with this script? Candidate: I'd like $150K. Comparable companies offer people with my experience $150K. Hiring manager: We'll offer you $100K. Candidate: I'll walk if you give me less than $140K. Hiring manager: Ok... Bye? Candidate: Okay, bye. [Takes a job earning $150k at one of those other companies] In general, I think the benefits of negotiating don't go to the individual. They go to next individual/the market. You repeat that script a few times and the hiring manager goes to HR and says nobody's taking the job unless they pay more. (If instead, you say "okay, fine I'll take $100k, I was bluffing" then that's what the next person is offered too.) > "Just negotiate better!" OK, great... how? My mental model is to approach it cooperatively. You're not trying to beat them. Talk about other data points if they say you're not being realistic, and talk about the reasons you're a better fit than they accounted for when you ask for more. They say they're better than the next company and you say you're better than the next candidate. But most of all, just make sure you actually have that alternative you're willing to walk away for. Interview while you have a job. Time your interviews so that you have options while this conversation takes place. YMMV. I've gotten like +10% from negotiating and +30% from walking away to take other offers, which should tell you the relative importance of each.
- PragmaticPulp 6y agoThe problem with most online salary negotiation advice is that it revolves around this idea that hiring is a 1-on-1 game between the candidate and the company. It assumes that the company has no other choices, so they must cave to the demands of the candidate. In practice, companies keep multiple candidates in the hiring pipeline and candidates usually interview with multiple companies at once. It's not a 1-on-1 game, it's an N-on-M game. Unless the specific candidate has something ultra-specific to offer, companies are fine with declining increased salary demands. I'm not suggesting that people shouldn't negotiate, but you have to keep in mind that neither side holds all of the cards. > Candidate: I'll walk if you give me less than $140K. > Hiring manager: Ok... Bye? As a hiring manager, I might have multiple candidates with different levels of seniority in my hiring pipeline. I might be willing to pay $300K for a senior, $200K for a mid-level, and $100K for a junior employee (example numbers). If my mid-level candidate threatens to walk unless I pay them $300K, I'm going to let them walk and give the $300K offer to the more senior candidate. I have no desire to overpay for a mid-level when I can get a senior-level for the same price. This is what most people forget in negotiations: You're not just negotiating against the company, you're negotiating against everyone else who wants the job. In practice, reaching equilibrium requires being willing to push the demands until your demands or offers are being rejected more than they're being accepted. That requires more sample points, so always apply to as many jobs as possible.
- Taylor_OD 6y agoWell this is bad negotiation for a lot of reasons. I've coached 1000's of folks on getting better offers. You are right that you have to have some leverage. But walking away is only one of many possible leverage points. You could also have other offers, have done well in the interview process, be walking away from an existing role that offers xyz that isnt offered at this company... What data points or pieces of leverage do you have other than I will walk? Because that is and should be the last piece used. If you are putting the first number out you're already working from behind. Company: We'll offer you 100K. Candidate: I'm really excited about the role for xyz reasons and I liked meeting with (insert persons name here) because it allowed me to learn about (insert reason you actually like the company here). I had a question about the offer. The base salary was a bit lower than I was expecting. Do you think we could get it adjusted? (If you have a point of leverage insert that here like, "My current comp is actually pretty close to this offer and I am expecting an promotion sometime in the next 6 months based on conversations with my manager"). I hope we can work this out over the next few days because I think this opportunity is the right next step in my career. Let me know what you think. Thanks! Company: "Okay we can do 115K" Candidate: Thanks so much for getting those adjustments. I was targeting closer to a 150K base salary. I am very invested in the role and the company though. I'm specifically excited about working with XYZ. Do you think we can move the base salary closer to that 150K mark? If not could we get a sign on bonus for the difference? If you could get to 150K base salary or something like 130K with a 20K sign on bonus I'd be ready to sign today and could start 2 weeks from Friday. Company: probably comes back with something less than 150K but something a whole lot better than 100K. I've had exactly one person I coached ever have their offer pulled. He basically said here are all the reasons your company sucks and I need XXXk to come work there. That's not negotiating. Negotiating is finding a point where you and the company both feel like you are both fairly valued.
- PragmaticPulp 6y ago> I've had exactly one person I coached ever have their offer pulled I've never seen an offer pulled, but it's common for companies to move on to other candidates when someone wants to draw out the negotiation process too long. This comes as a shock to some candidates who forget that companies can't wait around forever while they decide who to work for. The position must be filled someone quickly.
- tiew9Vii 6y agoI always see the advice never give your asking salary upfront. Recently I want to move work and willing to take a pay cut just to move so gone in with the honest approach which I am told is bad for maximizing salary. Right now I'm not to fussed about maximizing, it's just moving. The conversation normally goes: Company: What is your current salary Me: $XXX,XXX, that is negotiable as actively looking to move and will take less for the right company. *(I understand it's a high salary to the rest of the market where I am even though I am not in the US so salary is still well below US Junior FAANG) Then it's been one of two things: 1) Get offered 30-40% less (20% less is my ballpark, 25% for a company that really interests me) 2) Bye I've been told the job market is booming where I am but in 15 years it's the first time I've struggled to find a job although my skills are in demand overseas. I feel I'm fairly competent, I get told good things by people I work with and my salary has naturally grown through promotion based on my skills/performance yet I'm starting to question is it just me and I'm not that good why I am now struggling to find work despite going in to large orgs as a small dedicated team to do projects they couldn't deliver. It seems if I take a big paycut to where I was 5-10 years ago, forget 15 years of career and revert back to writing NodeJS/Python apps my luck will be better.