4 ms·
> the controversy seems to be more about alleged subtext than the actual facts presented. It's not about subtext, it's about the actual text, namely GG&S's nar
by masklinn 6y ago
> the controversy seems to be more about alleged subtext than the actual facts presented.
It's not about subtext, it's about the actual text, namely GG&S's narrative, the thesis it purports to prove, and how it goes about doing that. GG&S is not an innocent list of facts and a recapitulation of historical events, if it were nobody would care about it.
In case you are actually interested in "the controversy", the /r/askhistorians FAQ has multiple comments on the subject: https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/historians_views#wiki_historians.27_views_of_jared_diamond.27s_.22guns.2C_germs.2C_and_steel.22 https://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/wiki/historians_views...
- throwaway894345 6y agoI think it's worth reading through those criticisms, but in general I think they validate my claim that "it's about subtext". For example, a popular criticism is that GG&S wrongly paints Native Americans as inferior, but I don't know how anyone can read the book and genuinely walk away with that impression considering that it is contradicted by the very explicitly stated and much repeated thesis. Other criticism seems to be philosophical and esoteric ("Like, what does it really mean to be 'conquered', man?") or otherwise pedantic. I get the distinct feeling that much of the criticisms are ultimately rooted in political differences. I don't think Diamond intends to be controversial or political, but I suspect the GG&S thesis chafes with the political narratives that have come to, shall we say, 'conquer' the humanities. Anyway, I can't prove it, and I don't have any interest in debating it--just something to keep in mind for anyone who is digging into GG&S criticisms.