2 ms·
> But if you're already growing enough to survive on, the marginal effort to grow a whole lot more than that is not so big I don't think this perspective squar
by throwaway894345 6y ago
> But if you're already growing enough to survive on, the marginal effort to grow a whole lot more than that is not so big
I don't think this perspective squares well with the reality that starvation and malnutrition were realities for most people for most of history. I don't think it's just because they didn't think to do the extra bit of effort to generate a surplus. :)
> And you probably already grow more than you need anyway, so that you don't starve in bad years.
If you do grow enough to have such a reserve surplus, you don't trade that away or else you starve during the bad years. That surplus can only be either a reserve for hard times or currency for trade, but not both. If you want currency you have to have a surplus on top of your reserve.
> Seems to be that even subsistence agriculture will inevitably provoke some sort of economy, as long as other people are around.
"Subsistence" is kind of a confusing term because we use it in cases like feudal Europe where most people were subsisting because their surplus was being taken by their Lords. If you aren't generating a surplus at all, then you presumably don't get an agrarian economy (but you can still trade other things, like local minerals).
- thaumasiotes 6y ago>> But if you're already growing enough to survive on, the marginal effort to grow a whole lot more than that is not so big > I don't think this perspective squares well with the reality that starvation and malnutrition were realities for most people for most of history. I don't think it's just because they didn't think to do the extra bit of effort to generate a surplus. There are different ways for something to be a reality of life. Starvation was a risk throughout history in a way that it isn't today. But it wasn't something that happened to people under normal circumstances. The historical norm involves paying a large portion of your crop as taxes. Starvation tends to happen to many people at once, due to bad weather or other inclement circumstances. > If you do grow enough to have such a reserve surplus, you don't trade that away or else you starve during the bad years. You do. You always grow enough to have a surplus. But you can't just sit on it indefinitely or it will rot. So you personally store enough for winter, part of your in-kind taxes go to fill public granaries (which need to be continually refreshed), and otherwise you attempt to dispose of any remaining surplus as you can, often by giving it away.