5 ms·
Breaking news: advertsing company wants your personal information
- gasull 15y agoPlease, remove "breaking news" from the title.
- walrus 15y agoThe "breaking news" part is meant as a joke. The author is using it to indicate that they think it's obvious why Google made Google+.
- Kylekramer 15y agoBreaking news: a huge advertising company would like you to give them as much of your personal information as possible and encourages you to use their services more frequently, for more reasons, and for longer durations each time so they can show you more ads and make more money from the advertisers. I agree with most of this (since it basically says "I dunno, I don't like Google, they have a slim chance of creating a successful social network but there is a chance", otherwise known as "no shit, Sherlock"). But why is advertising depicted so deplorable by all these tech pundits? I honestly don't get why these people lionize the idea of creating good products sold for money and vilify the idea of creating good ads sold for money.
- william42 15y agoBecause of the whole «pleasing advertisers becoming more important than pleasing customers» thing, and the fact that tech pundits don't have to worry about having enough money budgeted for something.
- nl 15y agoMedia has dealt with this problem for years. Some media outlets let the advertising money corrupt them, and some don't. Just because some do doesn't mean all must. Exactly the same argument can be made about product companies. They can become more profitable in the short term by making shoddy products that break after a while. Is that a sensible strategy? I don't know, but I think it's exactly the same as saying that pleasing advertisers becoming more important than pleasing customers.
- william42 15y agoI don't really believe that part(but it's a meme that goes around), but the important part of this is that a tech pundit paid to evaluate a service doesn't really need to consider «Is this product worth its price» the same way you and I do when we decide whether to purchase it, because they're already purchasing it to evaluate it.
- stephth 15y agoPerceptually, ads don't offer value to the users experience, quite the contrary. This sums it up nicely: Another salient difference: Google: Thanks for looking at 100s of ads you hate. Apple: Thanks for buying 100s of dollars of stuff you love. https://twitter.com/#!/hotdogsladies/status/81018502886064128 https://twitter.com/#!/hotdogsladies/status/8101850288606412...
- ignifero 15y agoYou do realize twitter is a form of promotion, aka advertising. Also, isnt that comparing Apples to oranges
- stephth 15y agoYou do realize twitter is a form of promotion, aka advertising. You meant 'marketing', right?
- Kylekramer 15y agoBut if Google does its job, ads do offer value to the user. I hate bad ads as much as anything in the world, but the whole point of Google is to create good ads. And I think that is a noble goal.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- extension 15y agoGoogle's job is to sell ads to advertisers. Making the ads valuable to you is one strategy to achieve this, but not the only one.
- stephth 15y agoI'm not arguing if it's noble or not. But how often does an ad on Google add value to you as a user? I'm genuinely curious.
- 15y ago
- sudont 15y agoIt sets a precedent that tracking someone's movements is A-OK. Marco also has a stake in a wholly different idea of what advertising is. Notice "The Deck"s advertisement in his sidebar? He doesn't hate advertisements at all. He wants ad networks that are targeted, instead of being spammed out across every site and requiring invasive tracking to determine who and what product to show.
- Kylekramer 15y agoWhy is The Deck targeting one specific market fine but Google's larger scale targetting attempts spammy and invasive?
- sudont 15y agoI'm going to quote myself: "It sets a precedent that tracking someone's movements is A-OK." Anything that large will require metrics and user tracking to understand what to show. It matches the ads to the user, not to the site, by invading the user's privacy to understand exactly what to show.
- nl 15y agoIt sets a precedent that tracking someone's movements is A-OK. Not sure how you get this from Google building a new destination site. Doesn't this mean they'd do less cross-site tracking (since presumably they will spend more time on this new site)?
- extension 15y agoI honestly don't get why these people lionize the idea of creating good products sold for money and vilify the idea of creating good ads sold for money Here are some potential reasons, which I do not necessarily personally endorse: A good faith purchase of a product or service is a transparent and mutually beneficial arrangement. Ideally, each party acquires something more valuable to them than what they gave up and there is no deception necessary. Throw advertising in the deal and it becomes more of a competition. Now you have three or more parties involved and none of them have an explicit agreement on everything they are giving and receiving. The value flowing from consumer to producer to advertiser is left ambiguous. Anyone who has experience with contracts knows that ambiguity = conflict. Also, it could be considered inefficient, in a macro-economic sense, to spend resources just to convince people to buy other things. And finally, we've all seen what happens when advertising goes horribly wrong: spam.
- riordan 15y agoAnd here I was thinking this was a post about the MySpace deal.
- william42 15y agoDidn't Google+ set up a feature so that you can add someone who doesn't have Google+ and it will send them your posts, etc. using email? Precisely for this reason?
- Vitaly 15y agoI don't understand all the fuss about personalized ads. really. If Im going to see any ads I prefer them to be more relevant to me, not less. And if I do see something interesting and click I don't mind someone getting paying for it.
- seabee 15y agoAn upside to more precisely targeted advertising is that it lowers the cost of advertising, by way of reducing the number of eyeballs on an ad. A website with 1 million uniques can sell the space for $X to a big national business to whom it will be relevant to 30% of the userbase. Or, it could be divvied up between 20 local businesses from each user's location, selling the space to each for $0.1X, and being relevant to 50% of users. The website gets twice as much ad money, smaller businesses can afford to advertise, and users get slightly better ads. Is this really a bad thing?
- uxp 15y agoI agree and do not think that model of advertising is a bad thing at all. It is something I find valuable as a user. I think that Marco is more complaining about how the advertising company in question figures out that you are you at that IP address and computer combination. It's the back end analytics they employ that is building and refining a database of people that continually use their products, of which the users either can't see, access and review, or are ignorant of in the first place. Being helpless is something we all fear as humans, and not having any say as to what kind of information may be in that database scares some people. Is it something that we all should be aware of? Probably. Should it keep us up at night? Probably not. +1 or Google+ helps them refine who they think we are, but really, they don't care who any of us are individually, they care about what will interest us next.
- ignifero 15y agoFor all the rambling, Google adwords is still more effective, (ergo more lucrative) than Facebook advertising. That's because google knows a lot more than facebook knows about you. We literally tell them what we think every time we search. Facebook will have to devise a mind-reading device to beat that. And, imho, Google does not feel threatened by facebook. They have done nothing to harm facebook ads. On the contrary, facebook has banned Adsense from 3rd party applications.
- jeffchuber 15y agoJust wrote this on my blog, figured i'd copy over First of all–why do Facebook and Google care so much to canvas the web with little buttons to encourage users to share content? In fact–why do they care if users share content at all? Are they really that loving of the human race that they are doing so solely for our benefit? Of course not. A little background: - Facebook and Google know an inordinate amount of data about you - they track, store, and interpret every move you make through their services with the goal of figuring out who you are, mainly to sell to you. - But this wasn't enough, so Facebook introduced the Like button and Google +1. Now Facebook and Google can track your every move on the web - regardless of whether you interact with the button. Companies claim they delete this data, but only after they fully interpret it or extrapolate it into descriptive data. - The problem that Facebook and Google still face however - is that they collect massive amounts of data–but have a heck of a time monetizing it–because they essentially spied to get it in the first place. So what is the solution? Well, if the user actively shares the content–especially in a public realm but also privately, that user has consciously connected themselves to that content and monetization becomes easy. (This is why Gmail ads are creepy, but discounts from Foursquare checkins are welcome) more analysis here: http://knowit.posterous.com/google-a-reaction http://knowit.posterous.com/google-a-reaction