4 ms·
>With that continuing to increase, it might actually be statistically safer to keep it under your bed than at the bank's safety deposit. Whether that's true wo
by gruez 6y ago
>With that continuing to increase, it might actually be statistically safer to keep it under your bed than at the bank's safety deposit.
Whether that's true would depend on the false positive rate of civil forfeitures. Even if it's some absurdly high number (eg. 50%), you'd still need 2x as much civil forfeitures than burglaries for the risk to be equal (presumably nobody "deserves" a burglary). Also in theory civil forfeitures can be recovered, if you can provide documentation that the items aren't ill gotten gains. I'm not sure what the recovery rate for burglary is, but I'd imagine that P(assets recovered from civil forfeiture|you are innocent) is much greater than P(assets recovered from burglary).
- AnthonyMouse 6y ago> Even if it's some hilariously high number (eg. 50%) It's plausibly even higher than that. The incentive for civil asset forfeitures is for law enforcement to seize in exactly this sort of "a medium amount of money from a large number of people" type of situation. Because it makes this useless: > Also in theory civil forfeitures can be recovered "I got back my $9000 and all I had to do was pay $25,000 to a lawyer." And when people do the math on that and decide not to pursue it, law enforcement gets to keep the money. Hence the incentive for them to do it.
- Analemma_ 6y ago> Also in theory civil forfeitures can be recovered, In theory. It will cost you a shitton of lawyer fees that might exceed the amount you lost, and you can also expect to be constantly harassed by the cops during and after the process, plus forget about ever getting help from them again if you need it.
- syshum 6y agoI would say civil forfeiture is nearly 90+ % false... If it was a legit use of government power they would go for the better, more ethical criminal forfeiture where by they prove a person committed a crime and then take the assets related to the crime Civil Asset forfeitures are an end run around the 4th and 5th amendments, and should be viewed as unethical by every reasonable person
- brobdingnagians 6y agoIt also depends on where you live. Some places have higher rates of burglary than the average, and some much lower. A wealthy individual may have a higher chance of asset seizure, but less for burglary. But again, depends very much on your particular risk profile.
- Sohcahtoa82 6y ago> if you can provide documentation that the items aren't ill gotten gains This is just absolutely bonkers. "Innocent until proven guilty" was supposed to be a core tenet of our justice system. The court needs to prove that the money was acquired illegally, not assume it was, and then expect us to prove its innocence. They need to have evidence and a warrant before seizing. The "Second Amendment" types often claim that the Second Amendment protects the First Amendment. Well shouldn't it also enforce the Fourth Amendment?
- zhengyi13 6y agoPublic discussion (in favor) of applying 2A rights against 4A violations is utterly outside the Overton Window. As a practical matter, if one were to respond to a 4A violation with a 2A application, the 4A violators respond immediately with overwhelming force, after which you don't get to tell your story, and the violators get to write the report. Victors, history, etc.