4 ms·
I've always had my eye out for time travelers from our future (I've had my eye out for UFOs as well, with about the same rate of success). It sounds like Bardee
by JKCalhoun 6y ago
I've always had my eye out for time travelers from our future (I've had my eye out for UFOs as well, with about the same rate of success). It sounds like Bardeen could make the short list.
To this point I had been focusing on Edwin Howard Armstrong....
;-)
- newsbinator 6y agoWhat would be some good ways to distinguish a time traveler from a top-0.01% individual (of whom there are a million people on the planet)?
- wcarss 6y agoHaving fun with this: The elsewhere-mentioned "not making a big deal out of your success" might be a reasonable filter, because while a time traveler might almost unavoidably produce surprising advancements, they also wouldn't necessarily try to draw attention to themselves. You know, lest they fall awry of any wandering time cops. (Maybe not even to hide from them per se, given that for the hypothetical fun of it, we believe we could find them, but just to avoid some kind of prime-directive-rule against egregious self-enrichment, i.e. a "no playing god" kind of thing.)
- andi999 6y agoWinning the lottery to get clean funds.
- JKCalhoun 6y agoI guess I'm too stupid to imagine that even the top 0.01% of individuals could think of some of the really out-of-left-field ideas. The invention of Calculus might be another. That must have really made waves in the press. You know, when two time travelers set out to "invent Calculus" and by some unexplained coincidence they go back to roughly the same time in history. I mean, how does that happen?
- jeffreyrogers 6y agoIf you read some older textbooks calculus is explained in a more intuitive way, to where you could see how someone like Newton might've arrived at it geometrically. Mathematics has gotten increasingly formalized/rigorized, which has trickled down into the teaching of calculus, at the expense of obscuring the origin of some of the ideas.
- redis_mlc 6y ago> Newton might've arrived at it geometrically That's funny, because calculus is derived from calculating the area under a curve. :)
- rsj_hn 6y agoIt depends very much on how you define "calculus". If it's just a question of the fundamental theorem of calculus, then people like Isaac Barrow had already noticed that integration and differentiation were in some sense inverse operations, Fermat provided evidence of this by calculating integrals of polynomials, and I'm sure others did as well. But they did not supply a clear statement of a theorem with an accompanying proof, I believe mostly because of a lack of proper definition of the derivative, which was provided by Fermat, and almost immediately this was what Newton needed to prove exactly how differentiation and integration were related. I think it's no accident that once Fermat's definition (really, his method) of finding tangents was widely publicized, both Leibniz and Newton came up with the fundamental theorem. It was "hanging in the air", as all the pieces were on the table. Newton was not shy in crediting Fermat for giving him the definition he required. Math has many examples where the real breakthrough is identifying the precise definition of something that can be useful to form proofs. Once you have that, a flurry activity results in many proofs by other mathematicians. Cauchy's definition of limit triggered many results in analysis. Galois's discovery of a group or Enrico Betti's formulation of topology are other examples.
- dokem 6y agoJohn von Neumann definitely comes to mind. He was jokingly suspected to be an alien by his world-class intellectual peers.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- N1H1L 6y agoLeonardo Da Vinci then?
- evanb 6y agoThere’s a [perhaps apocryphal?] story about Onsager https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lars_Onsager https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lars_Onsager standing up at a conference and saying to someone discussing super conductivity, “No no no you’re off by a factor of two!” “A factor of 2?” “Yes, definitely.” He couldn’t explain the factor two under further questioning. It turns out he was exactly right, there is a factor of 2 that arises from the fact that to superconduct electrons form Cooper pairs. [Aside: Actually, related to Bardeen, since Cooper pairing was first really well explained by the BCS theory!] Onsager also had some calculational techniques nobody else understood; he could calculate statistical mechanics results in ways that really seemed alien at the time. He was understood to be completely right, years later; his method was similar to Feynman diagrams. When we were told these stories by my stat mech professor during my PhD, the [tongue-in-cheek] end of the story was “The only reasonable explanation is that Onsager was sent back in time.”