17 ms·
Perverse Downstream Consequences of Debunking
- h2odragon 6y ago"false political news" and "fact checking websites" are small band aids over large areas of contention that could alter the conclusions here. Who decides which politics are wrong? If that isn't "every individual who is faced with the choice, on their own" then is it still politics, or is it more herd management?
- shoemakersteve 6y agoPlease stop peddling this post-truth bullshit. No one is "deciding which politics is wrong", they're talking about people spreading things that are verifiably false.
- linuxftw 6y agoI disagree with your assessment. "Verifiably false" typically means "Corporate media says it's false."
- potta_coffee 6y agoMedia on all sides cannot be trusted. You're being downvoted by people that trust media.
- h2odragon 6y agoEveryone who tells you something had a reason to do so. If it wasn't "you paid them", then its a good bet someone else did. Even when you paid them to tell you the truth, you have to assess what they mean by "truth" and how honest their effort to deliver it was. If a doctor says "take this pill," do you huck it down or look it up and see if its something you actually wanted to eat? People trust "authority" too much.
- pessimizer 6y agoSaying that "fact-checking" websites are often crap isn't the same as saying there's no such thing as true and false. And have you read the paper? If you haven't, what are you spreading?
- Natsu 6y agoOf course there's truth and falsehood, but the fact checking is hardly 100%. For example: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qp3gy_CLXho https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qp3gy_CLXho Or you can read, e.g. Snopes' explanation that being convicted of making bombs to blow up a government building doesn't make one a "convicted terrorist" because there's no such crime as "terrorism."
- anotha1 6y agoIf you indirectly contribute to terrorizing people based on race because you provide aid and comfort to a racist, are you a terrorist?
- DyslexicAtheist 6y agoI think in that case the person is a racist. I find the label and term terrorism extremely troubling as it always can be spun as "what is a terrorist in one group might be the freedom fighter to the other" the label terrorism is usually only successful in the most homogenos and brainwashed cultures, where all complexity and nuance is stripped away. it's great for propaganda or when you need to criminalize a whole society of people.
- dang 6y agoCould you please not post flamebait and/or unsubstantive comments to HN? It's not what this site is for, and it destroys what it is for. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- allturtles 6y agoI don't know what the relevance of the Maher clip is. I stopped watching after a couple minutes, but all I saw was about how Democrats have false beliefs about COVID. I don't see what this has to do with fact checking. If you're referring to this Snopes (https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/blm-terrorist-rosenberg/ https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/blm-terrorist-rosenberg/), the "mixed" ruling seems perfectly reasonable. Saying someone is a "convicted terrorist" is a fuzzy claim, because there is no such charge one can be convicted of. It's not like "convicted murderer".
- oogabooga123 6y agoAsking “who fact checks the fact checkers” is not post-truth bullshit.
- Ekaros 6y agoThat is pretty reasonable thing. In science we do peer review. So why not in fact checking? Not that peer review process isn't corrupted in many ways, but still it is there. Not that I think similar process was possible in fact checking...
- dang 6y ago"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize. Assume good faith." "When disagreeing, please reply to the argument instead of calling names." "Eschew flamebait." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- commandlinefan 6y agoIf there were any real trustworthy fact-checking web sites, this study would mean a lot more, but there's a LOT of obvious bias on any of the fact-checking sites. That's not to say that nothing is objectively false (or true), but just to say that it's been "fact-checked" doesn't tell anybody which it is.
- Viliam1234 6y agoLiars adapt. Whatever becomes the popular method of checking the truth, they will create their own version of that tool. There is a similar arms race in science: Charlatans use scientifically sounding language. So you tell people "to be real science, it needs to be published in a scientific journal". Then the charlatans create their own journals. So you tell people "to be real science, it needs to be supported by a meta-analysis". Then the charlanatans create their own meta-analysis. Etc. It always takes some time to adapt, but if you tell people e.g. "always verify political statements at fact-checking websites", as soon as your idea becomes popular, politicians will create their own "fact-checking" websites. (Or take over the existing ones, whichever is easier.) I have some heuristics that I use for myself to determine what information I trust... but if they became public and popular, it would be quite easy to subvert them.
- burnished 6y agoCould you point to some examples? Most of the claims of bias I've seen have seemed to come from a person whose position isn't supported by reality, so it becomes easier to deny it and claim bias. But I haven't made a study of it and would love some counter examples.
- legulere 6y agoFor a democracy to work you need a basis of shared facts with opinions on top that need decision. In the later years we have seen a movement to erode this basis of democracy to make discussions on top of the basis of facts impossible and replace it with tribalist attacks against each other. Preventing fake news and fact checking is not about attacking sound political opinions, but about making them possible.
- h2odragon 6y agoI agree with you up to the point where "consensus" becomes a replacement for "verifiable fact", which is usually the next step in this chain.
- legulere 6y agoThere are also some things that need to be consensus without being fact-based, for instance that we want to live in a democracy.
- h2odragon 6y agoNot everyone does want to live in a democracy. I may disagree with them, but I'd like them to have the same ability to discuss their ideas as I do. Including advocacy up to the point of civic disruption, if not necessarily violence.
- dane-pgp 6y ago> For a democracy to work you need a basis of shared facts This is an Achilles' Heel which is unfortunately now well known by the enemies of democracy. An article from last year[0] highlighted this quite well: > The Kremlin specialises in offering alternative “narratives”: about who poisoned Sergei Skripal and Alexander Litvinenko, for example. The goal is to confuse the public and to spread the idea that the truth is unknowable. It’s a form of epistemological warfare. [0] https://www.theguardian.com/membership/2020/jul/12/covering-russia-and-the-west-putins-goal-is-to-make-the-truth-unknowable https://www.theguardian.com/membership/2020/jul/12/covering-...
- dovrce 6y agoCan't find the paper text, but here's the video showing it was an article about the Clinton Foundation and some snopes link https://youtu.be/WUDiBiKQxPk?t=141 https://youtu.be/WUDiBiKQxPk?t=141
- redis_mlc 6y agoActually, no. Virtually everything the leftist media has printed in the past 4 years has been shown to be false: - WaPo admitted Trump's phone call conversation to an election official was faked (used in the second impeachment) - Twitter has admitted they shouldn't have suppressed the Hunter Biden stories - fact-checking by many social media sites has been outsourced to interested parties, often controlled by the Dem party or CCP - there was no insurrection, since the 5 people who died were not killed by rioters, were mostly let into the Capitol by police, and didn't have guns. I could go on, but it turns out the left/Dems are outright daily liars.
- thomasmg 6y agoI would be interested in the sources of your claims.
- Applejinx 6y agoI'm not. It's become my opinion that there's a substantial political movement that will say or do anything for victory. Back in the day we saw Nazis and fascists take these rhetorical angles, because even many many years ago people had worked out that you could seize power by negotiating for victory rather than in good faith. The techniques of this are really long established and not even the technology is really new: back in the day, it was the existence of radio that was the technological breakthrough, and now it's control of things like Twitter and Facebook that correspond to that situation. The poster you're responding to doesn't appear to be operating in good faith, so the sources are irrelevant: they're purely vapor. You can just make stuff up and claim it, and if you can get someone to argue over the stuff, you've just become ONE SIDE of a both-sides narrative and legitimized the thing you made up. You can con yourself into believing it if you're a paranoid type, or you can be just out to manipulate. It does not matter whether you're sincere or not. It's the outcome you're after. I'm not interested in their sources. They're giving enough 'tells' that they're operating from sort of a post-reality position, and it really doesn't matter whether that is out of delusion or manipulation.
- thomasmg 6y ago
- stephc_int13 6y agoI think there is a lot more to say about this subject. I'll give a personal example, a few months ago, a leading French newspaper (Le Monde) published a debunk about the coronavirus origins, mostly trying to debunk that it originated from a lab in Wuhan. The problem is that what was presented as undeniable facts was in practice very poorly constructed, and we know today that things are not that clear cut. In my opinion, when something is debunked, it should be done in the most rigorous manner and stay as politically neutral as possible. Unfortunately, this is not what I am seeing.
- ergot_vacation 6y ago"Debunking" in the modern sense mostly just means calling someone an idiot for having a different opinion than you, with an added dose of self-assured smugness because obviously "science" and "the experts" and "everybody knows" are on your side. Debunking is bad enough when it actually comes from a place of real science, because even then the self-congratulatory nature of it makes people want to punch you rather than engage in a conversation. But when "the science" is really just a bunch of anecdotes, propaganda and Just-So Stories people in certain social circles keep repeating to each other ad nauseam, it becomes a complete joke.
- kiba 6y agoPeople are not convinced by facts and science, but by people in their trust networks. No amount of truth will ever convince someone who is predisposed to not believe you.
- guerrilla 6y ago> People are not convinced by facts and science, but by people in their trust networks. This is something I strongly believe and I wish more people thought about. Do you happen to know if we have a lot of scientific evidence for it?
- mistermann 6y ago
- daenz 6y agoThis seems hardly surprising. Publicly fact-checking someone makes them feel vulnerable and potentially stupid, so if they are not a person with integrity or humility, of course they are going to double down and get defensive. This is always been the case. It doesn't help that we choose to ride these people for years and never let them forget about their mistakes, so much so that some mistakes can be a death sentence for your future career. So what incentive is there to admit that they made a mistake?
- schoen 6y agoMaybe people presume that corrections represent a political or ideological attack. After all, I've seen people assume that sometimes on HN, which tries not to be a space for political flamewars and dunking. If you think that someone trying to correct you is likely to be a political opponent trying to score points, it makes sense that you would be vigilant and defensive. https://www.lesswrong.com/tag/arguments-as-soldiers https://www.lesswrong.com/tag/arguments-as-soldiers talks about one aspect of this where people might feel like they have to defend anything that "their side" says and dispute anything that the "other side" says. Sometimes people online actively try to defuse this by adding some context expressing sympathy or a non-judgmental or non-confrontational attitude. (That is, assuming that they merely want to counter mistaken ideas and information, and not people who hold or spread them!) I wonder to what extent that works.
- Lendal 6y agoDefensiveness? Possibly, but that's just one. I believe they do it mostly because they want to antagonize. They don't care if the info is false because it's all just a game anyway. If there's fact-checking, it proves that the information is valuable enough to cause someone of importance to waste time debunking it. Therefore, it is high-value material and should go viral even more. It's the same reason my dog steals socks. If someone is chasing them for a stolen sock, it must be of high value and therefore it must be stolen more frequently, carried away, and buried in the backyard. It's a part of the brain we share with dogs, apes, sheep, and cattle.
- daenz 6y ago
- kingsuper20 6y agoSince there's no such thing as news anymore, it's all op-ed, and the debunking sites all have a POV, I mostly just ignore peoples' politically oriented links except for primary sources. It's hard to argue with a video or a transcription.
- pwdisswordfish8 6y ago> It's hard to argue with a video or a transcription. You'd think so, but people either refuse to watch it, or claim they have watched it but then have no trouble saying something wild that's a complete contradiction.
- andrewflnr 6y agoOn the contrary, even with primary sources, there's almost no event that can't have its narrative completely turned around by additional context. In particular, such a primary source is almost always an anecdote rather than data. Data always introduces a possibility for bias. Truth is hard. There are no shortcuts
- beej71 6y agoIndeed--even if the video or transcription was completely fabricated, it's tough to argue with. :-/
- MikeUt 6y ago> It's hard to argue with a video or a transcription. There is video of many things. Choosing which ones to show and promote is itself a point of view, and greatly biases the political slant of news.
- kingsuper20 6y agoOf course context matters as does choice of material, but it's a heckuva lot better than hearing what someone thinks something means or (my favorite) 'unnamed sources'.
- themacguffinman 6y ago
- dreamlayers 6y agoFor the person doing it, sharing of such news can be more like the person expressing their own emotions than like sharing information. If that expression gets invalidated, the motivation to express those emotions remains.
- legerdemain 6y agoIn the end, what works is propaganda, propaganda, propaganda. Not truth, not facts, not numbers. Look at the "no campaign"[1] that got the ball rolling on removing Pinochet from power. They won on rainbows, birds, and flowers. "No" is happy good-feeling, "yes" is scary and bad. Don't correct, or debunk, or engage. Just flood the channels with your message. Infiltrate. Buy the opposition. That is how you govern effectively. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1988_Chilean_national_plebiscite#The_campaign https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1988_Chilean_national_plebisci...
- Applejinx 6y agoThis isn't an indictment of any side, even: it is a fundamental truth about the human mind. Not a one of us truly has rationality: at some point we're building our realities on sand. Anyone who's done therapy where they managed to deconstruct some of their childhood crap, and gained some re-evaluation of the deepest tenets of their existence (note: if that's you, then it was probably a good thing because you probably were suffering under some ugly nonsense absorbed as a child, that you're better off without!) knows the truth of this. There's no specific moral position to propagandizing the human mind. It's about what you're doing with it, and why. Bottom line is you can't do without that story, without that propaganda, so come up with a good story to go with your good purpose. It's story vs. story, all the way down (or up, if you're optimistic).
- tunesmith 6y agoI think this is another booolean vs spectrum issue. If that were universally true and people bought into it, it'd be a very sad world indeed. Luckily, most people really do try their best at keeping track of their values and living in accordance with them, even if we often fail around the edges. It's how we offer consistency and fairness to each other.
- tinalumfoil 6y agoCorrecting false articles with bot accounts and links to Scopes should not produce a change of mind in an educated person. Snopes hasn't been reputable since its original creator lost majority control in a divorce, and twitter bots are irreputable for reason I hope I don't have to state.
- m0llusk 6y agoThis study was limited to Twitter which may skew results strangely kind of like how many University studies are limited to wealthy young people of European descent.
- ch33zer 6y agoI wonder what kind of ethics are involved in this kind of study. The recent linux kernel/UMN affair [1] has made me more aware of what can or should be considered human research. [1] https://lwn.net/Articles/855479/ https://lwn.net/Articles/855479/
- rossdavidh 6y agoPresumably, if they put it before a review board, that board would have found that correcting people's misunderstanding of the facts of topic X is not unethical. Regardless of what one thinks of public "debunking" generally, the position of most in academia seems to be that telling people their news sources are not sound science, is not unethical.
- briantakita 6y agoThis begs the question, "who fact-checks the fact-checkers?" If the institutional "fact-checkers" & institutional opinion is incorrect, as it has been many times in the past, then the heavy-handed "correcting" of the critics is counter-productive to accurate & representative public discourse. IMO, a more useful approach is to bring forward all novel perspectives on a topic and let people make up their own minds. Many people don't like being told what to think & distrust the notion of "authoritative sources". However, full disclosure of knowledge & reasoned arguments demonstrates a good-faith account of a particular issue. Institutions having to resort to "correcting the record", especially when the title begins with "No, ..." & the predictable comparison to the flat-earthers, only sows more distrust in the institutions. The refutation by strawman may make the proponents of the institutional narrative feel more self-righteous & confident, but only insults & strengthens resolves to resist such narrative from opponents of the institutional narrative.
- tunesmith 6y agoI think it's really difficult to tease apart "believing something that isn't true" from "going out on a limb and sharing it in public". In other words, if someone responds badly, it's hard to say whether it's more because they hate discovering they're wrong about something, or more because they hate feeling humiliated by being called out in public. When sharing information is intrinsically tied to risking public shame if you're wrong... maybe that's what can be better managed.
- rossdavidh 6y agoSo, whenever you see someone debunking on Twitter, be sure to reply to that with a link to this study. :)
- motohagiography 6y agoTo a conspiracy theorist weak debunking is fighting fire with gasoline. There is another layer to this about how conspiracy theories can be very useful. If you have a good enough theory to warrant a denial, you know it's important enough to command attention, which makes it a co-ordinate or waypoint to triangulate the truth. Reporters and prosecutors traditionally do this by asking questions that make insane assertions so that they can get a denial co-ordinate, and use it as leverage to orient the narrative arc around the issue being denied. A conspiracy theory does something very similar. It's an accusation in the form of a question or unknown. The theorists themselves index too heavily on whether or not the plot they imagine is true, I think because they have this imaginary conditional that if only this horrible thing were true, only then the discussion includes them, and they become stakeholders in the events. This is the error of conspiracy theorists: that their perspective and experience would suddenly matter more if they were proved right. It won't. They don't have a plan for a world where the conspiracy theory is true, whereas I think the smart view is to look at conspiracy theories and consider how to survive and prevail in a world where not only are they true, but we can't imagine how deep they go. A big part of that is weighing the quality of denials they get. The efforts to debunk news are so partisan and crappy as to be evidence that the theories are "over the target" (in the lingo). Somewhere between the lie, the accusation, and the denial, the truth is located.
- eucryphia 6y ago"We identified N=2,000 users who shared false political news on Twitter" Who gets to say it's false? Activist journalists?
- crooked-v 6y agoThe study lists eleven specific claims that were tracked, all objectively false, six of which were primarily shared by conservative users and four primarily shared by liberal users.
- thu2111 6y agoThat was my first thought too but I looked at the list of claims. They're all very US centric and I hadn't heard of any of them, but none obviously jumped out as true but rated false. There was one about a fabricated quote assigned to a US politician, and I couldn't find any original source for it (and it was suspiciously extreme anyway). At the very least if one was incorrectly classified you'd need to do some legwork to demonstrate that.
- exporectomy 6y agoHow about just let people have their beliefs! We're supposed to be tolerant of different religions and even "creed". Universal same-think isn't necessary or even good. Let wrong ideas spread to people who want them. That's their choice. They get value from them. Stop trying to straightjacket everyone. In case you think it's dangerous for wrong ideas to be popular, then religions ideas are also dangerous so you should be trying to correct them too. Maybe they are and maybe you should, but at least be consistent instead of hypocritical.
- vmception 6y agoThe only option is to make additional conspiracy theories that are actually obvious verifiable reality But presented as conspiracy theories
- reader_x 6y agoWhat fascinates me is that everyone with a strongly held opinion had a point before they formed that opinion. Individual Flat Earthers once weren’t, Nazis once weren’t, and so on for the rest of us. Is there research on that point of opinion formation? Does it tend to happen, say, before a certain age, or at a point of emotional vulnerability, or following a major life transition?
- tpoacher 6y agoI really hate the word "debunk". The word derives from "de" and "bunk" -- an older word effectively meaning "bullshit". In other words, to "debunk" a claim means "to remove all the bullshit" from the claim. If a claim or argument is indeed, for all intents, a "bullshit argument", then it is quite fair to "debunk" it. But this isn't how most people use the word. Most people seem to say "debunk" as a means of saying "refuted", or worse, "rebutted". Just because an argument can be refuted doesn't mean it was a bullshit argument. Quite often an argument is perfectly valid, and only fails when the premises fail to be 'proven' conclusively. Not to mention that more often than not, 'proven conclusively' is a highly subjective notion to begin with. To say an argument was "debunked" is effectively a very rude way of dismissing / diminishing the person making the argument as being full of bullshit, when in fact their argument may have been a perfectly valid one, and possibly quite sound even, and may even have been useful in furthering the conversation.
- tlb 6y agoI only use the word in the sense you describe. The research in the article is about false political news, most of which is proper bunk. Occasionally, false political news arises from a genuine misunderstanding, but most of it is deliberate propaganda intended to smear the other side.
- tpoacher 6y agoIndeed. I have no qualms about using the word in its intended use. Even if I do consider it a bit unnecessarily rude.