3 ms·
Are you assuming FTL travel? If a civilization doesn't have FTL then expansion beyond their solar system seems unlikely. Yes, it is still possible with sub-lig
by tzs 6y ago
Are you assuming FTL travel?
If a civilization doesn't have FTL then expansion beyond their solar system seems unlikely. Yes, it is still possible with sub-light travel, but then you run into the problem of motivation.
When limited to sub-light speed trade between colonies and the home system is so slow that you probably can't usefully import resources from the colony systems.
When you are stuck with sub-light, colonizing another system (unless perhaps you are in a place with a lot of stars close together) is more accurately described as spending a whole lot of effort to establish another system that then won't really have much interaction with or effect on your system.
Even the old classic of kicking out your undesirables who then go on to start a new civilization doesn't really work, because it is so expensive. If you dislike them so much that exile is the only answer and you don't have someplace in your system to exile them to you are far more likely to just kill them.
- kingsuper20 6y agoThis assumes that the expanding intelligence isn't machine-based.
- 7thaccount 6y agoThis. Paul Davies (prominent SETI researcher) states in one of his books that he wonders if biological life is a transitory phenomena.
- deeviant 6y ago> If a civilization doesn't have FTL then expansion beyond their solar system seems unlikely. Yes, it is still possible with sub-light travel, but then you run into the problem of motivation. > When limited to sub-light speed trade between colonies and the home system is so slow that you probably can't usefully import resources from the colony systems. I mean this seems to disregard our entire history as a species. There have always been "others" within a population that seek, above anything else, to find a new place to go in order to live life they way they want to. We are also moving into an age where data and knowledge are raising to supreme importance. Both of these things can be transported at the speed of light, so a multi-solar system civilization that is able to increase is total resources available to acquire new information and knowledge will be at an advantage. Then, of course, there is the desire to preserve the human species as a whole by "spreading our seeds" so to speak.
- goatlover 6y ago> I mean this seems to disregard our entire history as a species. There have always been "others" within a population that seek, above anything else, to find a new place to go in order to live life they way they want to. If the energy and time requirements are great enough, space between solar systems will work as the same sort of barrier space does for the rest of life on Earth.
- tzs 6y ago> I mean this seems to disregard our entire history as a species. There have always been "others" within a population that seek, above anything else, to find a new place to go in order to live life they way they want to. Sure, but those who have successfully done that have either went to a place near enough that they could take all the food and other supplies they would need during the trip there with them, or have went to a place where food and other resources were available on the way. I can't think of any human group that did a migration that had to cross a span that provided no food or drinkable water and was too long for them to cross on what food and water they could carry with them. With sub-light migration to other solar systems we are talking about crossing empty spans that will take several lifetimes to cross. There are ways to deal with that, but they are likely to be major undertakings that require a heck of a lot of resources so that to do it you need widespread support from the people who aren't going. My guess is that you'll need a pitch much stronger than "We want to go someplace to live our way" (especially since the people who leave won't be the ones who arrive at their destination--it will be their descendants).