3 ms·
Anonymous chats with verified memberships have a number of interesting applications. For example, I seem to recall Mencius Moldbug discussing them as a mechanis
by gwern 15y ago
Anonymous chats with verified memberships have a number of interesting applications. For example, I seem to recall Mencius Moldbug discussing them as a mechanism for regime change.
The idea being that in a totalitarian regime like North Korea (or to a lesser extent, the countries of the 'Arab Spring'), it's well known that even the elites are discontented and would support the overthrow of the regime. But there is a knowledge problem, a coordination problem, that they cannot be sure of the support of all the other elites and factions. If they declare their opposition publicly, the still loyal elements will dispose of them. But private declarations which are safe also do not reach enough people to constitute any sort of Schelling point. (This is one of the main points of protests: taking risks, demonstrating solidarity, and a genuine costly signal. If there's sporadic gunfire and suppression from the regime, all the better - scare away the pikers.)
On the other hand, suppose you had a secure anonymous forum for, say, just military officers? With one of the anonymous e-voting schemes integrated to get a headcount of subversive questions like 'how many of us officers would support a regime change?' Then maybe public protests would no longer be the best way to solve the coordination problem for coups...
- bugsy 15y agoThat's a very interesting post. The problem is that in such extreme cases as North Korea, if the government is setting up this discussion list or has any access to it there is no possibility that the conversation was really anonymous. If the government doesn't have access, then mere silent participation without informing would be considered treason. Even if there was anonymous speech going on, Jung merely needs to approach each participant one by one and have them identify which statements were theirs. By a process of elimination, you find who the dissidents are, even if they refuse to talk.