3 ms·
No HDD on the market has ever been variable-speed. What you may be perceiving as a change in RPM could just be the difference in harmonics of the spindle motor
by userbinator 6y ago
No HDD on the market has ever been variable-speed. What you may be perceiving as a change in RPM could just be the difference in harmonics of the spindle motor as you change the dampening.
As for particles on the platters, the keywords to search for are "thermal asperity". An excess of them, or ones that are actually stuck to the platter, can cause damage but as you have noticed, what usually happens is the head just knocks them out of the way and heats up slightly, causing a misread and subsequent retry (hence the slow speed). If you power on a working drive and then remove the lid, the air currents will keep any new particles from sticking to the pllatters.
By pushing down on the lid, however, (simulating screws) it sped up and down a few times before failing. The harder I pushed the less it vibrated and the more it worked, until I finally had it returning I/O, albeit slowly.
It's more likely that you were adjusting the actuator angle. See the bottom picture in this article for comparison (also a WD drive from around the same era):
https://hddguru.com/articles/2006.02.17-Changing-headstack-Q-and-A/ https://hddguru.com/articles/2006.02.17-Changing-headstack-Q...
- williesleg 6y agoThe outside of the disk spins faster than the inside of the disk asshole.
- rsync 6y ago"No HDD on the market has ever been variable-speed." I'm not sure that's true ... I remember from one of the Sun Performance Tuning manuals there is a chapter on disk performance and there was a throwaway line about "non commodity disks". Specifically, that there were, in the past, disk drives with heads that moved independently. I don't know much more about "non commodity disks" - I think they must have been prevalent in the 70s (?) - but variable speed doesn't sound much weirder than independent head movement ...
- rzzzt 6y agoDual head stacks were once a thing, and there was a recent thread about them as well: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26502216 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26502216
- userbinator 6y agoMultiple heads moving independently have many advantages, varying the spindle speed doesn't; it takes a lot of energy to change the speed of the platters, and doesn't really provide any benefits. Zoned bit recording already takes advantage of the varying linear density, and doesn't require changing the platter speed. In the 70s, disk drive motors would likely be mains powered synchronous induction motors, which are constant speed and where the traditional speeds of 3600, 5400, and 7200 originated.
- wmf 6y agoI've only heard about one model of dynamic RPM (DRPM) hard disk and only prototypes were made.
- bradknowles 6y agoSony 3.5” floppy disks used to be variable speed. I knew about that at the time I interviewed for a position as an intern at Imprimis in 1989, just before they got bought by Seagate. The guy I was interviewing with smiled smugly and said “we’ve got a better solution — we vary the speed at which we read and write data!” As a result of that job, I ended up writing what I believe to be the first FAQ for hard drives and stiction — in 1989. I haven’t been able to find a copy of it, however. Dunno if there would be any useful information in that FAQ for the OP, but it would be interesting to check it out and see. That is, if anyone can find a copy.
- Teknoman117 6y agoI was about to call you out, but turns out the thought that WD green drives were variable RPM was just people misinterpreting crappy documentation from WD on how fast they operate. They didn't publish speeds because they reserved the right to sell any speed of drive under that label without telling you...