3 ms·
The author is making a subtle mistake; evolution doesn't mean like-parent-like-child. Evolution is likely selecting for, eg, people who have children at a cert
by roenxi 6y ago
The author is making a subtle mistake; evolution doesn't mean like-parent-like-child.
Evolution is likely selecting for, eg, people who have children at a certain ratio of introverted-extroverted.
Introverted, disagreeable, high-contentious types make, for example, great scientists. A population (call it A) that produces a reasonable number of such people is at a huge advantage compared to the alternative that only produces extroverted agreeable types (call them B).
Population B will be more competitive at breeding, but population A will win any conflict with B because they'll have a bunch of weirdos in the back room producing a lot of high quality science (a classic stereotype with some foundation in truth).
Note that men are much more likely (something like 4x) to be "completely homosexual" compared to women [0]. I'm betting this is because having a few men who opt out of the race to pass on their genes and focus on other stuff is a massive advantage to the society that hosts them. Look how much of a force gay men have been in culture for example.
Locally catastrophic for breeding, globally optimal for society. The equilibrium isn't for all offspring to maximise their chance of breeding. The optimum is for the community to thrive.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_sexual_orientation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_sexual_orienta...
- edejong 6y agoI came here to say essentially this. But what is the name of this process where groups of people select for variety instead of optimal individuals?
- roenxi 6y agoI'm confident that it is evolution. People don't evolve, populations evolve.
- dTal 6y agoYou're confident, but evolutionary biologists largely don't agree with you. I strongly recommend you glance over some of the reasons why at the Wikipedia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection In a nutshell - "The problem with group selection is that for a whole group to get a single trait, it must spread through the whole group first by regular evolution... a group where altruism was universal would indeed outcompete a group where every creature acted in its own interest, so group selection might seem feasible; but a mixed group of altruists and non-altruists would be vulnerable to cheating by non-altruists within the group, so group selection would collapse."
- dTal 6y agoIt's a type of natural selection called "group selection", and it's taboo, because it's very tempting to invoke it to explain away all sort of apparent paradoxes - but it requires very tricky circumstances to work at all, if it even can, and it's rare for the explain-away-ers to bother to show why it works in their particular instance. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Group_selection
- arve0 6y agoAlso, why would evolution select for an equilibrium? With so many parameters I would expect oscillation.