2 ms·
That's why I said "evolving". Making engines better, introducing FSW when it was introduced, and so on. The F9-like boosters that could have been made around
by pfdietz 6y ago
That's why I said "evolving". Making engines better, introducing FSW when it was introduced, and so on. The F9-like boosters that could have been made around 1972 would still have been much better than the shuttle turned out to be.
What one should object to in this scenario is the idea that the conventional aerospace companies, and NASA, would have done anything like this, when their internal incentive structures pushed them away from it.
- bodhiandphysics 6y agoWe did build an f-9 like booster around the time of the shuttle, the delta ii. It doesn’t compare to falcon. Neither does Antares, built at the same time as the f-9
- pfdietz 6y agoDelta-II was not a F9-class launcher. The first stage thrust (ignoring strapons, which one should because F9 doesn't use them) was less than 1/7th that of the F9. A closer match was the Saturn IB.
- bodhiandphysics 6y agoDelta ii was designed around boosters! Also when falcon 9 was developed its target payload was ten tons to Leo, similar to delta ii’s 8
- pfdietz 6y agoF9 1.0's payload to LEO was 11.5 tons, vs. (up to) 6.8 tons for Delta II. Yes, D9 was designed around boosters. This means D9 is a different kind of design than F9. I'm contending that a more F9-like design, like Saturn 1B, could have evolved into something like the F9 over time. D-II could not have.
- pfdietz 6y agoDII, not D9