3 ms·
The slippery slope argument. If we don't hold the line, pretty soon we'll be calling astrology a science. Psychology has the potential to be a science, but it's
by okareaman 5y ago
The slippery slope argument. If we don't hold the line, pretty soon we'll be calling astrology a science. Psychology has the potential to be a science, but it's early and we don't know enough. Electricity wasn't a science until Michael Faraday made it one. On the other hand, astrology has no potential to be a science.
- DangitBobby 5y agoThe slippery slope argument is only a fallacy when slipping down the slope doesn't actually happen (or can't possibly follow from the described beginning state). Some slippery slopes do actually exist. For example, if you put your weight over the line, you can literally slip down a slippery slope. On the subject of categories, they cease to be useful when the contents of the categories can no longer tell you anything about the category itself. The further you get down this axis, the less useful the category is. So any dilution of the strength of a category by overly broad inclusion should be scrutinized.