4 ms·
Your position seems bizarre to me. I want to live in a society where I can do what I like (which in my case involves founding institutions that help propagate
by gumby 6y ago
Your position seems bizarre to me.
I want to live in a society where I can do what I like (which in my case involves founding institutions that help propagate things important to me like free software, and als making plenty of money).
My descendants? Some upbringing and a good education and then they are on their own. What would be the point of giving them some money or a company? Some sentimental knickknacks: fine.
I consider inheritance anti-democratic and not part of the kind of society I would like.
- CyberRabbi 6y ago> I consider inheritance anti-democratic I consider restricting the ability for people to provide inheritance to their children by force of state anti-democratic.
- gumby 6y agoAre you objecting to something someone suggested? Without the force of state or a private army it’s pretty difficult for anyone to leave anything to someone after they kick the bucket.
- CyberRabbi 6y agoProtecting someone’s property is not the same as taking away someone’s right to their property. When the state does the former, it is a liberal state, when it does the latter it is a tyrannical state. If you aren’t suggesting the state take away my ability to provide inheritance to my descendants, then what is the function of calling inheritance anti-democratic? Are you suggesting that a true democracy does not allow individuals to leave inheritance to their descendants?
- userulluipeste 6y ago"what is the function of calling inheritance anti-democratic?" As I understand it, legacy can be (and definitely is) used as a tool for wielding power, which (democracy wise) gets naturally viewed as a problem. That's not to say that inheritance is bad or that it causes more harm than good. Personally, I think that denying inheritance will take away an important working drive for many people, which in turn will invite in the said people a cool off after achieving certain level of personal comfort. All that while the society at large would benefit more from the same people to fulfill their working potential than from diminishing whatever vector of risk to the optimal function of democracy. Also, whatever much or little one may achieve in life, at one point it must be passed to someone else, due to our mortal nature. I'd rather let the owners have control over how and whom they pass that to (i.e. to someone they know and maybe even had the chance to personally educate), as that to me seems the best setting for having things built in the long run.
- altusbrown 6y agoThat attitude does tend to align more with mine, with some important distinctions. It would also be interesting to compare long term societal/general impact and survival with that attitude. My reasoning is that being exposed to the influence of power and wealth when someone is young is a bit like having them snort cocaine - unlikely to produce a long term successful human). Is not taking wealth when it is available and not giving it to your progeny a long term survival/genetic benefit or not? Wouldn't really change anything, but I guess curiosity in the face of a unclear benefit is pretty much the definition of us here. :)