4 ms·
Tariffs don't protect local businesses, they charge local customers more in order to punish foreign companies. Besides being a tax on your own population, they
by astrange 6y ago
Tariffs don't protect local businesses, they charge local customers more in order to punish foreign companies. Besides being a tax on your own population, they have bad effects on other local businesses both because you didn't predict their foreign inputs and because they're always followed by retaliation on your own exports.
- gambiting 6y ago>>Tariffs don't protect local businesses, they charge local customers more in order to punish foreign companies. That statement literally makes no sense whatsoever. No offence. Tariffs are paid by the importing entities, so the idea is to make it more expensive to import foreign goods than locally produced ones. I am aware that some countries like the US use tariffs punitively but that's like using a hammer to make an omelette.
- rascul 6y ago> Tariffs are paid by the importing entities Seems those entities would likely raise prices to cover increased tariffs.
- swiftcoder 6y agoThus making the prices of their local competitors more attractive. Ergo, protecting local producers. Notably, not to protect businesses in general - if your business is importing/retailing exclusively foreign goods, then tariffs are explicitly designed to disadvantage you versus someone retailing local products.
- clairity 6y agoonly if there is positive price elasticity, and that depends on market dynamics (price is a function of both supply and demand). for instance, if there is a local alternative that's 10% more expensive, you might have that 10% leeway available to you to increase prices, but not if demand drops sharply (negative price elasticity) because substitutes exist or the good isn't as essential as it seemed.
- Y_Y 6y agoIf you buy something directly from another country then you are both a local customer and an importing entity. I bought some electronics from Hong Kong recently and had to pay 40% again when it entered the EU. There aren't any local businesses who make these things.
- gambiting 6y agoIf you were importing from HK to EU I'm not aware of many tariffs that would apply on electronics, I guess you just paid VAT and customs duty, and neither is what I'm talking about here.
- magicalhippo 6y agoNorway has import duties on apples a few months a year. Tell me how that's not to protect the income of our local apple farmers. We have import duties on beef, with quotas given throughout the year based on how large local production is versus how much local demand is. Tell me how this is not done to protect local meat producers. I could list many more such examples from the agricultural sector.
- astrange 6y agoYou are punishing people who want to eat apples and beef for the crime of being able to pay less for it. This doesn't protect businesses who want to sell apple and beef based products for less money using foreign raw inputs. And what retaliation are you getting in exchange for raising these tariffs?
- gambiting 6y ago>>You are punishing people who want to eat apples and beef for the crime of being able to pay less for it. That's an incredibly weird way of looking at it. Consumers don't have some god given right to cheap apples and beef. The government has a duty to protect both consumers and producers, because it's so closely interlinked - if you destroy your own industry to import cheap beef and apples what will you do if those foreign companies decide not to sell to you any more? Or if you can't import from them because there was a draught or a disease outbreak? Like, you think that the only think we should optimize for, ever, is the final price for the customer, everything else is not important, right? After all doing anything else is "punishing" customers for the "crime" of wanting cheap produce? Like, please take no offence, but that's incredibly short sighted.
- blueblisters 6y agoIt’s pretty well accepted that tariffs lead to overall worse outcomes for all parties involved. Some reasons: - Someone mentioned price elasticity below. The demand for the product might actually drop because of higher prices from local producers - Local producers become less competitive, especially if the imported item was not cheaper because of lower labor cost but because of innovation - The downstream high-value supply chain becomes less competitive if tariffs are applied to an intermediate/low-value product There is a narrow space in which tariffs might work and that is when they’re temporarily used to shelter local producers from outside competition with the hope that they can quickly build capability and scale of their global peers.