4 ms·
The....what? If you make a product X and someone imports product X from a country where labour is 1/10th of the price, you go bust. In a lot of cases countries
by gambiting 6y ago
The....what?
If you make a product X and someone imports product X from a country where labour is 1/10th of the price, you go bust. In a lot of cases countries impose customs duties to protect those businesses, because it's better to have a working industry than cheap goods.
Which part exactly is a lie?
- henvic 6y agoTariffs aren't imposed to protect the population, but specific well-connected players who lobby for such protections to avoid competition.
- gambiting 6y agoWell, such a wild accusation requires a source. I can name several examples where tariffs were introduced specifically to protect local industries, mostly farmers, because it would be cheaper to just import foreign apples or carrots than locally grown, but obviously if you allow that to happen you don't have an apple or carrot growing industry next year. You could argue that "rich farm owners lobbied politicians to avoid competition" but you couldn't be any further from the truth. It was demanded by the farmer cooperatives and unions through protests, not some wealthy magnates.
- sokoloff 6y agoIs it more important to serve the farmers or the broad population who wants to eat apples and carrots?
- mind-blight 6y agoIt really depends on the context. Focusing only on the price a costumer pays as your main metric ignores a lot of potentially negative externalities. One recent example in the US: a lot of small local business were suffering because the Chinese government was heavily subsidizing shipments to the US. So much so that it was cheaper in some places to get a product mailed from China than from across the street. The US started pushing back with tariffs while appealing too the universal postal union postal union. That kept the US businesses from going under while the UPU slowly went through the process of forcing china to follow their rules. And that's ignoring pollution, all the negatives that happen for the whole population when an industry and/or small businesses collapse within a country, and other negative externalities
- wizzwizz4 6y agoTariffs are supposed to protect the population.
- henvic 6y agoNo. They aren't supposed to protect the population. This is a lame excuse to implement it without popular revolt. I was born in Brazil and lived there for most of my life. When I was young, it was, in practical terms, forbidden to import computers and cars to the country to protect the "nascent" national industry. I know very well from a close point of view how tariffs can make everyone's lives miserable. My father had to import his first computers illegally. Knock-offs IBM PCs bought in Paraguay. Imagine in the early 80s to travel from NY to San Francisco to smuggle computers over the border because a mad man in the state decided you cannot trade goods with someone who lives far away. This is what customs is about. Protectionism is not only dumb, it's vile! Pure evil! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7njIlZ2xYq0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7njIlZ2xYq0
- magicalhippo 6y agoFor me, banning the import of legal goods is something else. Here in Norway you're allowed to import certain cheeses that are also produced locally, but you'll have to pay a 300% or so duty on them. So it's strongly discouraged but not banned. Similar for other food stuff. And as I mentioned in another comment, there's quotas given for a lot of these food items, that exempts duty for a certain amount of imported goods. This way the government can give strong protection for the amount produced locally, while meeting consumer demand via imports. I feel this is a good compromise. Textiles is another example which have a 12% duty, a relatively minor protection. And that's about the extent of our protectionism.
- henvic 6y agoNo. A good compromise is leaving business between A and B if you are C. If you produce the best textile in the world and charge only a penny, but someone would prefer to pay a pound for something awful from overseas, they should have the liberty to do so. It's none of your business how other people trade.
- gambiting 6y agoThis is the craziest idea I've ever heard when it comes to economics . Isn't that basically the libertarian "everyone should be allowed to do whatever the fuck they want to do" approach? As in....do you not recognize that society might want to value having functional industries and employment above absolute freedom for businesses? And as someone else already pointed out - there are whole bunch of externalities that we all pay for by allowing this unfettered and unlimited trade. With your approach if it was cheaper to ship fresh salad 20k miles than buy local, it should be allowed because after all, why should you interfere with local businesses? Sometimes it is a matter of national security too, where one country knowingly attempts to destroy another's industry by dumping their product at cost prices - great for consumers I imagine you'd say. But again, you are being very short sighted.
- dennis_jeeves 6y ago>Tariffs aren't imposed to protect the population, but specific well-connected players who lobby for such protections to avoid competition. henvic, you won't convince the dimwits here, I assure you.
- astrange 6y agoTariffs don't protect local businesses, they charge local customers more in order to punish foreign companies. Besides being a tax on your own population, they have bad effects on other local businesses both because you didn't predict their foreign inputs and because they're always followed by retaliation on your own exports.
- gambiting 6y ago>>Tariffs don't protect local businesses, they charge local customers more in order to punish foreign companies. That statement literally makes no sense whatsoever. No offence. Tariffs are paid by the importing entities, so the idea is to make it more expensive to import foreign goods than locally produced ones. I am aware that some countries like the US use tariffs punitively but that's like using a hammer to make an omelette.
- rascul 6y ago> Tariffs are paid by the importing entities Seems those entities would likely raise prices to cover increased tariffs.
- swiftcoder 6y agoThus making the prices of their local competitors more attractive. Ergo, protecting local producers. Notably, not to protect businesses in general - if your business is importing/retailing exclusively foreign goods, then tariffs are explicitly designed to disadvantage you versus someone retailing local products.
- clairity 6y agoonly if there is positive price elasticity, and that depends on market dynamics (price is a function of both supply and demand). for instance, if there is a local alternative that's 10% more expensive, you might have that 10% leeway available to you to increase prices, but not if demand drops sharply (negative price elasticity) because substitutes exist or the good isn't as essential as it seemed.
- 6y ago